Close X Cookies are necessary for the proper functioning of 24hGold.com. By continuing your navigation on our website, you are accepting the use of cookies.
To learn more about cookies ...
EnglishFrench
Gold & Silver Prices in

Does Gold Ever Pay?

IMG Auteur
Published : April 18th, 2012
665 words - Reading time : 1 - 2 minutes
( 1 vote, 5/5 ) , 1 commentary
Print article
  Article Comments Comment this article Rating All Articles  
0
Send
1
comment
Our Newsletter...

 

 

 

 

Is it fair to characterize gold bullion as an investment...?


WHY BOTHER investing? Five years into the financial crisis – and more than a decade after the US market hit its big top in real terms – you might well ask. Especially now that cash, bonds, Treasuries and stocks pay between zero and sweet nothing in yield, just like gold bullion.


The aim if not the outcome of investment is simple, however. "Investing [is] the transfer to others of purchasing power now with the reasoned expectation of receiving more purchasing power – after taxes have been paid on nominal gains – in the future," as Warren Buffett
wrote earlier this year to his Berkshire Hathaway shareholders.


Buffett should know all about that. The world's third richest man, he famously seeks under-priced investments that look set to rise to fair value. Delivering a better than inflation return (after taxes are paid), that makes tomorrow's consumption cheaper for the investor in terms of what s/he puts at risk today.


Put $10 in, take $20 out, and you're ahead – provided that inflation (or tax) hasn't eaten the real value of your extra money meantime. Because as Buffett says, it's real purchasing power that matters. So here's what US citizens trying to make future consumption cheaper have had to contend with since roundabout the time he got started investing.





As you can see, you now need $2.30 to enjoy the quantity of goods and services you got for 27¢ back in 1957. But that's only in terms of plain cash, stuffed in your wallet or purse, rather than invested in anything as simple as a bank deposit account.


So here's how holding cash-in-the-bank has performed instead, after interest. You have to pay tax on such income of course, and that's included here at the 15% rate charged to the average US household. By way of comparison, non-yielding gold bullion is shown too – this time with the current US capital gains tax of 28% included instead.




Keeping cash in the bank has helped fend off inflation long term, even after you've paid 15% tax on the interest. But there have been times when keeping cash on deposit failed to keep its head above water – the 1970s of course, but now also over the last decade. Gold bullion, in contrast, has gone the other way in both of those periods. Similarly, gold's long bear market (1980-2001) coincides on our chart with a long winning streak in the real value of cash.


Of course, the United States' official Consumer Price Index is often called into doubt. The methodology has mutated so much, it's hardly the same index today as it was in the late '90s, let alone six decades ago. Raw materials, in contrast, are still priced in Dollar and cents. So what do the broad commodity markets say about the investment value of gold versus cash?




Yes, the CCI index has also been subject to change, but its inputs remain the most heavily used natural resources (crude oil, copper, wheat etc) and the computational changes are tiny next to the mutation of the official Consumer Price Index.


Just for kicks, the violet line above measures the CCI in the CPI, showing how the "real price" of commodities steadily fell (oil crises aside) in the 45 years to 2002. And once more, you could have enjoyed a very much lower cost of food, energy and other basic materials again simply by opting to buy gold or put cash in the bank.




Like earning interest on cash, gold bullion has indeed proven itself a decent investment under Warren Buffett's definition. Because it has reduced the real cost of raw materials over the long run, albeit with major shakes along the way. Gold lost half its tax-adjusted value for investors between 1980 and 2000. Cash in the bank has lost more than that in the 12 years since.


Cash up, gold down in short. And vice versa as the charts show.



 

 

<< Previous article
Rate : Average note :5 (1 vote)
>> Next article
Adrian Ash is head of research at BullionVault.com, the fastest growing gold bullion service online. Formerly head of editorial at Fleet Street Publications Ltd – the UK's leading publishers of investment advice for private investors – he is also City correspondent for The Daily Reckoning in London, and a regular contributor to MoneyWeek magazine.
WebsiteSubscribe to his services
Comments closed
  All Favorites Best Rated  
Sigh...gold is insurance - it is meant to preserve wealth...if it adds wealth, great, but people should not invest in gold as they do in stocks. As for the numbers used for anything these days, it gets one nowhere in establishing price. Between debasement and the tricks used (most of which defy logic), it is difficult to compare gold (spot) to other phony numbers and indexes. Take the leveraged long/shorts. ETFs, certificates, and other paper out of gold valuation, and the number would be higher. Who even knows accurately what a USD id worth - it certainly has people leaving its world reserve position in droves - not to mention the dumping using sovereign wealth, hedge and mutual (institutional) by many countries --- now only 60% or so of trade is via the petro dollar.

Government numbers are bad enough but mark to mark versus market valuations plus dark pools leave us with NO benchmarks. In valuing gold or silver, use ounces, because nobody know what an ounce of bullion is worth, any more than they do a currency when measured against a bizarre little basket of currencies. We are all acting out a fiction. It makes me feel silly, and I avoid it whenever possible...as I do with elastic tard sticks. What an idiotic period in financial history.
Latest comment posted for this article
Sigh...gold is insurance - it is meant to preserve wealth...if it adds wealth, great, but people should not invest in gold as they do in stocks. As for the numbers used for anything these days, it gets one nowhere in establishing price. Between debasemen  Read more
SirJames - 4/18/2012 at 10:04 PM GMT
Top articles
Latest Comments
The Fed Has Bankrupted the US In Order to Create Another Bubble
29 AprSilverthumb
I believe this bubble will pop, the big question is when. I underestimated the power of the Fed and monetary policy. I believe that during the We...
The parable of the cards
28 Aprdom1971
Please let me take this a step further if I may... because I see an opportunity to highlight a particular concern of mine. Let us ignore f...
Debate Over Electric Trucks: Let’s Get It On
25 AprJerry82
Thanks Mish, this was a very insightful and thought provoking piece. I've often heard concerns about the weight of these new electric trucks and th...
No, The Junior Mining Stocks Are Not About To Implode - Dave Kranzler
25 AprJerry821
Thank you Dave for this excellent article. I agree with your well thought out critiques that point to junior miners being just fine. Relying on tha...
Gold Bullion Erases $10 Bounce Despite French Election, N.Korea Ris...
25 AprJerry82
I don't know how much I'd trust the listed GLD holdings. I always found GLD's structure to be a bit strange. They so famously claim that they are 1...
The Story of Gold Money, Past, Present and Future, by Edwin Walter ...
18 AprJerry82
Thank you for this very thought provoking piece Nathan. I have not read any literature from Edwin Walter Kemmerer before but I am inclined to pick ...
Gold Prices Slip $10 After Breaking Downtrend as UK's May Seeks Bre...
18 AprSam Maher3
"That left the GLD gold ETF needing a 2017 high of 849 tonnes in bullion backing." I frequently see you make these claims on GLD's holding...
Bombs Away!
17 Aprprljr-1
James tribe owns trump.
Most commented articlesFavoritesMore...
World PM Newsflow
ALL
GOLD
SILVER
PGM & DIAMONDS
OIL & GAS
OTHER METALS