Close X Cookies are necessary for the proper functioning of 24hGold.com. By continuing your navigation on our website, you are accepting the use of cookies.
To learn more about cookies ...
EnglishFrench
Gold & Silver Prices in

Another Look at What 'Worked' in the Great Depression

IMG Auteur
Published : February 08th, 2012
791 words - Reading time : 1 - 3 minutes
( 3 votes, 3.7/5 ) , 4 commentaries
Print article
  Article Comments Comment this article Rating All Articles  
0
Send
4
comment
Our Newsletter...
Category : Editorials

 

 

 

 

Here is a fairly simple picture of some of the major metrics during the Great Depression. Too simple yes, but it tracks most of the major indicators.

Hoover followed a policy of 'deleveraging,' that is, allowing for the economy to liquidate its prior excesses without changing much else. The Fed did respond to this crisis by expanding the monetary base fairly significantly as you can see.

The recovery began under Roosevelt, who declared a 'bank holidy' and struck at the heart of the problem, clearing the banking system. But he also followed through with a major currency devaluation, stimulus programs, and significant financial reform.

And that last point is the most important. Hoover's Fed supplied stimulus, but there was really nothing done to fix the system that had caused the Great Crash of 1929 in the first place. And I suspect that if Roosevelt had not taken strong steps to clean up the fraud in the stock market and the banking system, his own stimulus would have fluttered and failed.

Now the common knee jerk reaction to this from those who study the schoolbook given by the monied interests is twofold.

First, that Hoover simply did not go far enough, and if they had only allowed the Depression to continue to deepen, eventually it would have bottomed and things would have improved. I think the answer is clear, in the examples of Italy, Germany and Japan. When an economy is tortured to that extent, the people do not continue to endlessly suffer in silence. They react, badly, and take matters into hand one way or the other.

They say you cannot fix debt with debt. And I say that like most simplistic slogans it is intended to mislead. The real issue is reform and how the debt is used and the gains distributed.

Secondly, they say that the Roosevelt recovery did not last. And it did not continue on a steady trajectory. The Fed engaged in some policy errors and caused a secondary slump in the late 1930s. And the world economy remained troubled. Roosevelt also faced an obstructionist Congress, and a Supreme Court that overturned many of his New Deal programs.

He also faced an attempted military coup d'etat funded by
a few of the monied interests who also busy doing business with Mussolini and Hitler, as testified by one of its more decorated war heroes, but the history books don't like to talk about that. Just another nut job.

Globally, the monied interests seemed to have choose amongst three options: 1. Go along grudgingly with reform and accept a smaller percentage of the overall economy (Roosevelt), 2. Fund an oligarchic takeover of the government and seek to control it (Hitler), 3. Sew your wealth into the dresses of your children, and die with them in a basement (Russia).

The US, like all other nations, has plenty of its own dirty little secrets that no one likes to talk about.

The point of this is that austerity following a financial collapse based on fraudulent imbalances does not work and almost always leads to civil disorder. And that stimulus alone does not heal the damage, although it does help to ease the pain if applied correctly.

No, the most important ingredient for a sustained recovery is to reform the abuses that allowed for such a spectacular bubble of excess to exist in the first place. It was all about the misallocation of productive capital and the negative effects of monopolies and financial frauds on the real economy.

At some point this lesson will be burned into our minds by the continuing stagnation of the unreformed economy, even if it is sold as 'the new normal' and not so bad on paper. It will be a living hell for many, and they will eventually push back, and then things will be resolved, one way or the other.

I hope that the new school of economic thought that rises out of the ashes of what we have now is more serious and mature and thoughtful, if not wise. But I have not found many economists capable of such original thinking, even among those who claim to carry the progressive banner.

And certainly not among the ideological schools, who start with an a priori set of premises and then beat reality and torture the market participants to death with them and their supporting statistical and logical fallacies. Since these schools are based on top down principles and assumptions, they are notoriously slow to change and adapt, but often most vociferous and extreme in their arguments, with adherents whose allegiance is less informed by the intellect and an actual understanding of things, and more like a belief system based on stubbornly held slogans and prejudices.






 

 

Data and Statistics for these countries : Russia | All
Gold and Silver Prices for these countries : Russia | All
<< Previous article
Rate :Average :3.7 (3 votes)
>> Next article
IMG Auteur
Jesse 13 abonnés
Visit Jesse's Cafe Americain for refreshing news on the markets
Latest comment posted for this article
Hey Platinoid...are you giving yourself down arrow ratings on posting ? Read more
S W. - 2/8/2012 at 8:09 AM GMT
Top articles
Latest Comments
Why Are Central Banks Terrified ...
20:33overtheedge
Thank you for explaining this far better than I could. Perhaps a few of the "deflation" religious fanatics will finally recognize there is NO d...
When Even the Fed Is Confused, W...
18:52user4779
Great article! Will you please do a follow-up article on precisely how a fixed ratio can be maintained---the right way and the wrong ways---and per...
Job Site of the Future: Unmanned...
18:46Doom
Exactly! That's why the cotton gin and industrial steel mills closed down immediately and had no effect on the economy. Oh, wait. Nvm.
Marine Le Pen Soars Into Lead in...
30 Januser47791
Some of the polled people must be voting for 2 presidents: the combined votes total at least 134%.
Are You Sure You Want to Delete ...
30 Jan077885258331
are you mad if you save where the government can see it touch it feel it they will take it, either through inflation, taxes or confiscation th...
Greece's Debt: Guess Who Pays in...
28 Janbelville19071
I have read better analysis from Adrian: Greece is in an extremely strong position and the EC has to give in. If Greece leaves and defaults on its ...
Koos Jansen: India's silver expo...
26 JanDoom
Heh, the title doesn't match the subject. I would have been shocked if India was really exporting silver, much less exporting a record.
Education is Too Important Not t...
26 Jansam_site1
Right on Ron. Americans don't understand that we have been fed a distorted version of history taught in our schools. The constant attempts by cri...
Most commented articlesFavoritesMore...
World PM Newsflow
ALL
GOLD
SILVER
PGM & DIAMONDS
OIL & GAS
OTHER METALS
Comments closed
  All Favorites Best Rated  
How about the great 'fuck-over' of the tax-payer that American progressives imposed upon the tax-payer.
What about the sweet deals cut by the 'representatives' of Germany and 'American bankers' for war reparations.

"monied interests", are you fluffing kidding? The Rothschilds? Nut jobs? Statistical and logical fallacies?

What about the economic implosion in Europe because of the repayment schedules your beloved bankers imposed?

Jesse, you are at the trough of everything you claim to blame.

Fluff your pillow, and go back to sleep.

"Spectacular Bubble of excess"...yeah, something a new government policy can fix!!!!

Dear readers, do not make any gold or silver trades based on this historical revisionism.

You might as well watch the Flintstones and make your trades based on that.

Yeah Jesse, you are a true counselor.

Go fluff your pillow.

Rate :   0  6Rating :   -6
EmailPermalink
Hey Platinoid...are you giving yourself down arrow ratings on posting ?
SW., well not intentionally, thanks for pointing it out.
I usually enjoy reading Jesse, although he's as left as Howard Kacsynski.
The reason the Supreme Court overturned Roosevelt's New Deal was because they saw the structural socialism it would cause.
I got a bit ticked.

Rate :   1  3Rating :   -2
EmailPermalink
PS:

The editors didn't like my historical description of life under Stalin, which happens to be factual, and 'edited' the section out.

Mind you, they publish pure grotesque profanity from Kunstler, and we get to read it.

Maybe a leftist didn't like reading the truth and reported it, so the boss reacted.

Might account for the red arrow......

Really.......I'll start hitting the 'report abuse' button more often myself.

Half the columns presented here are in the 'rant' category.
Rate :   1  3Rating :   -2
EmailPermalink
Subscribe to 24hGold’s daily market briefing
  • Prices and data of precious metals in 119 currencies and world mining companies
  • Daily analysis of the economy, markets and more
  • Free, daily and indispensable
Stay informed, subscribe now !
* Your email will never be shared.