current state of investors' collective fear means the odds remain against
those who own stocks and in favor of those who short stocks or remain
Capture These Collective Thoughts & Fears: The S&P 500 is
now below the critical level of 741. We should expect rallies, but they do
not mean much unless we can close and hold above 741. Investors' collective
hopes and fears, along with perceptions of value and future economic
activity, are captured in charts. These are the same factors (hopes, fears,
and perceptions) that determine the value of financial assets. When you
understand this concept, you can appreciate the value of charts and technical
analysis when making investment decisions. In the final analysis, what we at
CCM "think" about the markets does not matter any more than what an
individual investor may happen to "think". What does matter, and
what drives assets prices is what the market collectively thinks. It did not
matter that Warren Buffet thought stocks were cheap late last year -
collectively investors disagreed with him - he lost money. Ultimately, Buffet
may be proven to be right, but there is no need for us to argue with the
market. When the market begins to see what Mr. Buffet sees, it will show up
clearly on a chart. Last week, we presented the chart below outlining the
risks if support near 741 on the S&P 500 did not hold (the chart was
created after the close on 2/26/09).
did not hold and stocks dropped in two trading sessions from 752 to Monday's
intraday low of 699 (a decline of 7% in two days). The fact that major
support was broken last week is not simply a break of a line on a chart. It
represents investors collectively deciding the state of the economy and
future economic outlook do not currently justify the S&P 500 holding
above 741. The S&P 500 held above 741 for over three months, which
represented the collective belief the November 2008 and 2002-2003 lows would
hold. Investors no longer hold that belief. The shift in investors'
perception should not be ignored. The graph below shows a little closer view
of the 2002-2008 support including the activity of the last two trading days.
Street, many money managers start their careers using a purely fundamental
approach. Over time, many come to appreciate the value of technical analysis
(charts). In fact, it is not unusual for fundamental managers to eventually
add technical analysis to their tool kit. Some managers go so far as to
abandon the fundamentals all together and focus exclusively on the technicals
(not something we recommend). It should tell you something about the
effectiveness of technical analysis that in my fifteen years on Wall Street,
I have never seen a manager who started with a technical approach convert to
a purely fundamental approach - never.
we believe the best approach is to use both fundamental analysis and
technical analysis. However, if given the choice of only using one, we would
not hesitate to choose the technicals because of their usefulness in sound
money management. Currently, the fundamentals remain weak. The technicals are
weak too. The primary trend in stocks remains firmly down, which means the
collective thoughts of investors on average are negative relative to the
attractiveness of stocks. A trendline is not simply a line on a chart - it is
a way to measure the current tendencies of investors - the same investors who
are going to determine the value of your investments. It literally pays to
understand what they are thinking and feeling. Currently, investors remain
cautious and fearful. The current state of investors' collective fear
means the odds remain against those who own stocks and in favor of those who
short stocks or remain defensive.
Weak Attempt To Calm Markets: This morning the Wall Street Journal
ran a story 'Bad Bank' Funding Plan Starts to Get Fleshed Out. The
timing of the government's endless financial bailout announcements is always
interesting. With all major stock markets hitting new bear market lows, we
can guess recent dialogue concerning the markets in Washington went something
President, with both the November 2008 and 2002 stock market lows no longer
providing support, the S&P 500 could fall rapidly toward 600. Sir, we are
afraid the selling could begin to pick up significantly given the recent grim
economic news and the sure to be ugly employment report due this Friday. We
suggest getting some new information out about our yet to be detailed plans
to deal with toxic assets. We don't have much to release, but we can ask the
reporters to use words and phrases like" (all included in the Journal's
- "Filling in
some of the blanks"
- "No decision
has been made on the final structure"
- "Many details remain
- "The Fed
and the Obama administration also are mulling..."
- "The idea
might not move forward."
President, this will give the market a reason to hope. We have to do something!"
think after the universally negative reaction to Treasury Secretary
Geithner's much anticipated February 10, 2009 announcement the administration
would realize the financial markets want details. The market needs to know
the rules of the game. Today's Wall Street Journal article contains very
little new information and it hedges all the information with "no
decision has been made on the final structure" of the plan. These vague
announcements tend to generate some limited short-term interest that
inevitably is followed by the same concerns about the lack of specific
above, we should expect rallies in stocks, but they do not mean much
unless we can close and hold above 741. The primary trend of investors'
collective outlook for stocks remains negative.
Ciovacco is the Chief Investment Officer for Ciovacco Capital Management,
LLC. More on the web at www.ciovaccocapital.com