Chart usGOLD   Chart usSILVER  
 
Food for thought
Confidence in money is suspicion asleep
Benjamin Disraeli  
Search for :
LATEST NEWS  :
MINING STOCKS  :
Subscribe
Write Us
Add to Google
Search on Ebay :
PRECIOUS METALS (US $)
Gold 1373.504.80
Silver 21.710.01
Platinum 1426.50-9.50
Palladium 698.80-11.00
WORLD MARKETS
DOWJONES 15300-16
NASDAQ 3479-4
NIKKEI 13245238
ASX 484247
CAC 40 3839-22
DAX 8192-38
HUI 2550
XAU 1030
CURRENCIES (€)
AUS $ 1.4042
CAN $ 1.3649
US $ 1.3403
GBP (£) 0.8561
Sw Fr 1.2323
YEN 127.5400
CURRENCIES ($)
AUS $ 1.0481
CAN $ 1.0186
Euro 0.7461
GBP (£) 0.6388
Sw Fr 0.9195
YEN 95.1600
RATIOS & INDEXES
Gold / Silver63.27
Gold / Oil13.99
Dowjones / Gold11.14
COMMODITIES
Copper 3.13-0.02
WTI Oil 98.18-0.26
Nat. Gas 3.950.05
Market Indices
Metal Prices
RSS
Precious Metals
Graph Generator
Statistics by Country
Statistics by Metals
Advertise on 24hGold
Projects on Google Earth
In the same category 
Banning Short Selling
Published : August 11th, 2011
674 words - Reading time : 1 - 2 minutes
( 0 vote, 0/5 ) Print article
 
    Comments    
Tweet
Keywords :   Facebook |

 

 

 

 

In fall, 2008, the US banned short selling of certain stocks.  It triggered a massive short-covering rally.  Then, without the shorts in the market, prices went into freefall.  When prices are falling, the shorts (when taking profits) are the only bidders.  Markets don't crash because of short sellers.  They crash because the bid is withdrawn.

 

Every time governments have tried to manipulate markets and impede price discovery, it's always had the same disastrous result.  And yet today, several European countries have announced bans on short selling.

 

My prediction is that, after a possible massive short covering rally and possibly piling-on by momentum chasers, whatever securities are not shortable will collapse.  One reason for this is that a ban on short selling tells would-be buyers that there is something wrong.  And they should withdraw their bids.  Then gravity will take over, as first one seller needs to sell "at the market" (i.e. on the bid) and there is no real bid.

 

I wrote the following in response to a friend's Facebook post.

 

First, contrary to popular misconception, the purpose of the stock market is not to go up, ratcheting higher and never lower. Its purpose
is price discovery. This is because it allocates capital, and just as it is important to allocate more capital to the most productive
enterprises, it is equally important to deprive the least productive enterprises of more capital (which they are destroying). Short selling
is a key part of this process.

 

Second, unlike long buying, short selling tends to be done by more sophisticated investors. With long buying, there is a limit on one's
potential loss but no limit on the possible gain. Short sellers face the opposite: a limited gain and unlimited losses. This tends to make
them more careful, more selective, and to hold positions for much shorter periods of time.

 

Third, short sellers keep everyone else honest. When people can act free from negative consequences or downside, they tend to become more
and more aggressive and take risks. Imagine if I said go into the casino, and if you win keep it. But if you lose, I will pay you back.
This is also called "moral hazard". Greed is one of the two motivators for market participants. People want to make lots of money. Fear is
the check on it. People really want to avoid losses. Short sellers can inflict losses when people become overly, irrationally greedy.

 

Fourth, short sellers will tend to dampen volatility. The higher a price goes above its fundamentals, the more short sellers will be
attracted to come in to the market. Perhaps more dramatically, when a market is plunging, short sellers may be the only bid in the market.
Consider how a real market works. Forget "the price" of something.  There are always two prices: the bid and the ask (offer). The bid and
the offer are made by different people, motivated by different forces.  And there are asymmetries. Since money is the most liquid, most
trusted thing in the system, it's never bad to sell an asset and get cash. So there is never a case when the offer is withdrawn. But the
bid is a whole different story. The bid is withdrawn under crisis or stress. This causes a market to plunge, and thus more bids are
withdrawn. Short sellers, on the other hand, have a natural tendency to want to take profits. And thus buy back the shares they shorted.  And thus put in a bid.

 

Fifth, markets are driven by arbitrage. If the price of copper goes down, an arbitrager can put on the following trades simultaneously:
buy copper (long) and short a copper mining company. If two similarly situated companies are trading at a stable ratio of share prices, and
one's price suddenly starts to collapse (assuming that it's not caused by anything real) the arbitrager can buy the fallen shares and short
the shares of the other to bring the spread back to normal. There are endless examples of arbitrage, which involve at least one short "leg".

 

 

 

 

 

Tweet
Rate :Average note :0 (0 vote)View Top rated
Previous article by
Keith Weiner
All articles by
Keith Weiner
Next article by
Keith Weiner
Receive by mail the latest articles by this author  
Latest comment posted for this article
Be the first to comment
Add your comment
TOP ARTICLES
MOST READ
TOP RATED
MOST COMMENTED
Editor's picks
RSS feed24hGold Mobile
Gold Data CenterGold & Silver Converter
Gold coins on eBaySilver coins on eBay
Technical AnalysisFundamental Analysis

Keith Weiner

Keith Weiner is a technology entrepreneur and president of the Gold Standard Institute USA. He was the founder of DiamondWare, a Voice Over Internet Protocol software company, which he sold to Nortel in 2008. He is an Objectivist who has his PhD from the New Austrian School of Economics, with a focus on monetary science. Keith, who currently trades and analyzes precious metals and commodities, advocates a return to a proper gold standard and laissez-faire capitalism. He lives with his wife near Phoenix, Arizona.
Keith Weiner ArchiveWebsite
Most recent articles by Keith Weiner
6/17/2013
6/15/2013
6/5/2013
5/22/2013
5/16/2013
All Articles
Comment this article
You must be logged in to comment an article8000 characters max.
 
Sign in
User : Password : Login
Sign In Forgot password?
 
Receive 24hGold's Daily Market Briefing in your inbox. Go here to subscribe or unsubscribe.
Disclaimer