Close X Cookies are necessary for the proper functioning of 24hGold.com. By continuing your navigation on our website, you are accepting the use of cookies.
To learn more about cookies ...
EnglishFrench
Gold & Silver Prices in
In the same category

EU Financial Tax Portends Loss of Market Leadership

IMG Auteur
Published : January 30th, 2013
882 words - Reading time : 2 - 3 minutes
( 1 vote, 5/5 ) , 1 commentary
Print article
  Article Comments Comment this article Rating All Articles  
0
Send
1
comment
Our Newsletter...
Category : Editorials



Although it was barely noticed by the American press, on January 22nd, EU finance ministers approved a new "Financial Transactions Tax" (FTT) that has implications for market competitiveness around the world. 

The move was conceived as a Franco-German initiative and was supported by seven other EU nations, including the entire bloc of highly indebted southern tier nations, to reach the minimum nine nations required to press ahead under the EU's so-called, 'enhanced co-operation procedures'. If at least one of the transacting parties involved is an EU resident, the tax will impose a one tenth of one percent tax (on both sides of a financial transaction) on secondary market trades in equities, bonds, securities and REPOS. Derivatives will be taxed at a lower one hundredth percent. 

Although limited presently in scope and at an apparently low rate, the tax will nevertheless provide an extra layer of financial bureaucracy that will dissuade some market participants from transacting in the Eurozone. It should be patently obvious that transactional fluidity is supportive of efficient markets and ultimately of economic growth. It is only in the poisonous, anti-capitalist, post-crisis environment that such a measure could be passed. More importantly, the measure is a "supra national" tax that helps to pave the way towards a global taxation system. Not only will such a system be economically damaging, but it will be devoid largely of effective democratic accountability. 

In its March 2011 tax meeting in Brussels, the EU had originally proposed a "Financial Activities Tax" (FAT), a more comprehensive, and potentially more destructive, EU-wide measure. The opposition to the tax was so fierce, most notably from Great Britain, that the FTT was proposed as a compromise. 

Ignoring the role of the central banks in the financial debacle, the German Finance Minister commented lamely that, "The financial sector must appropriately participate in bearing the cost of the financial crisis." According to the EU's Tax Commissioner, Algridas Semeta, the FTT decision was a "major achievement for EU tax policies." Those who believe, as I do, that the EU's covert intent is to erode the traditional independence of the world's financial markets, particularly the dominance of London and New York, certainly share those sentiments. 

In an economic impact analysis running to over 1,000 pages, the EU Commission estimated that the FTT would raise $76 billion annually. The commission admitted that this would cause a 10 percent drop in securities transactions, a 70 percent fall in derivatives trading and result in a loss to the EU's GDP of some 0.53 percent. All this in an EU economy struggling now to prevent a recession falling into a depression! Of course, the Commission failed to consider any resulting lost tax revenues implied by a fall in GDP.

On its face, it was clear that the idea for both the FAT and the FTT was a product of left wing ideology of soaking the so-called rich, but devoid of any real understanding of how free markets operate.

If such a tax were imposed in single country market, in the UK for instance, it would encourage a massive flow of business to other national markets. The EU must feel that its size and status will protect it from such an eventuality. Few suspect that the FTT will offer economic benefits that would outweigh the harm it will impose. But that is not the criteria by which the measure will be judged by EU leadership. What if FTT is designed not as a tax to encourage more responsible investing,  but as a covert weapon to win political control of Europe? 

FTT is a supra national tax imposed on top, and independent of, national financial taxes. Once the infrastructure to enforce and collect the tax is established, the tax rates can be raised relatively easily. Most importantly, once such supra national taxes are established, they suffer from very little if any democratic supervision. 

EU Tax Commissioner, Algirdas Semeta, has said that the Commission has arrived at a means of levying a tax that prevents investors from relocating. The tax will be imposed on both the buyer and the seller of a financial instrument so long as either of the two parties is based within any participating EU country. This means that even investors in London or New York accustomed to paying only their domestic taxes may not escape the new tax completely. 

At a time when governments should be encouraging the free flow of capital, this measure moves us exactly in the wrong direction. Combined with the heightened regulatory scrutiny in the United States (President Obama's appointment last week of the first former federal prosecutor to head the Securities and Exchange Commission), the move bolsters the belief that the West will likely cede financial market leadership to the freer and more vibrant markets in the Pacific. 

John Browne is a Senior Economic Consultant to Euro Pacific Capital. Opinions expressed are those of the writer, and may or may not reflect those held by Euro Pacific Capital, or its CEO, Peter Schiff.

Subscribe to Euro Pacific's Weekly Digest: Receive all commentaries by Peter Schiff, John Browne, and other Euro Pacific commentators delivered to your inbox every Monday! 

Order a copy of Peter Schiff's new book, The Real Crash: America's Coming Bankruptcy - How to Save Yourself and Your Country, and save yourself 35%!
Companies Mentionned : Southern |
<< Previous article
Rate :Average :5 (1 vote)
>> Next article
John Browne is the Senior Market Strategist for Euro Pacific Capital, Inc. Mr. Brown is a distinguished former member of Britain's Parliament who served on the Treasury Select Committee, as Chairman of the Conservative Small Business Committee, and as a close associate of then-Prime Minister Margaret Thatcher. Among his many notable assignments, John served as a principal advisor to Mrs. Thatcher's government on issues related to the Soviet Union, and was the first to convince Thatcher of the growing stature of then Agriculture Minister Mikhail Gorbachev. As a partial result of Brown's advocacy, Thatcher famously pronounced that Gorbachev was a man the West "could do business with." A graduate of the Royal Military Academy Sandhurst, Britain's version of West Point and retired British army major, John served as a pilot, parachutist, and communications specialist in the elite Grenadiers of the Royal Guard. In addition to careers in British politics and the military, John has a significant background, spanning some 37 years, in finance and business. After graduating from the Harvard Business School, John joined the New York firm of Morgan Stanley & Co as an investment banker. He has also worked with such firms as Barclays Bank and Citigroup. During his career he has served on the boards of numerous banks and international corporations, with a special interest in venture capital. He is a frequent guest on CNBC's Kudlow & Co. and the former editor of NewsMax Media's Financial Intelligence Report and Moneynews.com. He holds FINRA series 7 & 63 licenses.
Latest comment posted for this article
... the German Finance Minister commented lamely that, "The financial sector must appropriately participate in bearing the cost of the financial crisis." ... That is like saying the garbage collector must bear responsibility for the landfill filling up.  Read more
overtheedge - 1/30/2013 at 11:12 PM GMT
Top articles
Latest Comments
China is about to overthrow Lond...
28 Febneville
This a good slap in the face for the downright crooked bullion banks,traders that have been front running ie algorythm trading etc It had to ta...
A Salvo in the Battle for the Go...
27 Febovertheedge
I would argue that the devil is in the details, i.e. the definition of money. What the people of the US are using is currency. Currency bei...
A Salvo in the Battle for the Go...
26 FebFrankinca1
Sort of written for a PHD in economics, which gold believers (myself) are not often that well educated, have difficulty following. The definition o...
A Salvo in the Battle for the Go...
26 Feb07788525833
The dollar has a monopoly over all other types of money which is rammed down peoples throats by gun and drones , any one wanting to change this...
In Search of the Magic Wand: Car...
25 FebDoom
Yes, stay away from University of Phoenix, a school with a 9% graduation rate, that only gets students because it spends $200,000 a day on Google a...
Emails From Kiev: Free Speech Va...
25 Febovertheedge
"The problem is, the asshats associated with Poroshenko are even worse than he is." I'm assuming you mean the predators in the US White Ho...
The Bull Case For Gold This Year...
25 Febdepourcq1
You talked about all the wrong reasons that gold will rise or fall, their is only one that everyone should know. The US has a debt of 18.134 trilli...
The Bull Case For Gold This Year...
25 Febneville
The fact that you are very lowly rated might be one of two things .1.You have been playing this card to often (Bear Joker) 2,The other is that you ...
Most commented articlesFavoritesMore...
World PM Newsflow
ALL
GOLD
SILVER
PGM & DIAMONDS
OIL & GAS
OTHER METALS
Mining Company News
Tinka Resources(Ag)TK.V
Announces AGM Results
CA$ 0.27-12.90%Trend Power :
Corporate news
Silver Standard(Ag-Au-Cu)SSO.TO
Early Glance: Silver companies
CA$ 6.57-0.90%Trend Power :
Corporate news
Pan American Silver(Ag-Au-Cu)PAAS
Early Glance: Silver companies
US$ 9.68+1.04%Trend Power :
Corporate news
Gold Fields(Cu-Ni-Mo)GFI
Early Glance: Gold companies
US$ 4.65+0.87%Trend Power :
Corporate news
Randgold Res.(Au)GOLD
- Total Voting Rights
US$ 79.19+0.24%Trend Power :
Corporate news
Continental Precious Min.(Ag-Au-Co)CZQ.TO
Engages Golder Associates for the Next Step in the Development of the Viken Project
CA$ 0.56-6.67%Trend Power :
Corporate news
Beaufield Res.(Ag-Au-Ni)BFD.V
Reports Annual General Meeting Results
CA$ 0.04-11.11%Trend Power :
Corporate news
Probe Mines(Ag-Au-Cu)PRB.V
Leading Independent Advisory Firms ISS and Glass Lewis Recommend Shareholders of Probe Mines
CA$ 4.94+0.82%Trend Power :
Corporate news
Newmont(Cu-Le-Ni)NEM
Why the Earnings Streak Will Continue for Newmont Mining (NEM) - Tale of the Tape
US$ 26.33+0.08%Trend Power :
Corporate news
Newmont(Cu-Le-Ni)NEM
Increased Earnings Estimates Seen for Newmont Mining (NEM): Can It Move Higher? - Tale of the Tape
US$ 26.33+0.08%Trend Power :
Corporate news
Comments closed
  All Favorites Best Rated  
... the German Finance Minister commented lamely that, "The financial sector must appropriately participate in bearing the cost of the financial crisis." ...

That is like saying the garbage collector must bear responsibility for the landfill filling up.

The financial sector just passes the costs on to the consumer. The consumer foots all the bills. So just how does the financial sector bear any actual costs?
Subscribe to 24hGold’s daily market briefing
  • Prices and data of precious metals in 119 currencies and world mining companies
  • Daily analysis of the economy, markets and more
  • Free, daily and indispensable
Stay informed, subscribe now !
* Your email will never be shared.