Close X Cookies are necessary for the proper functioning of By continuing your navigation on our website, you are accepting the use of cookies.
To learn more about cookies ...

Gold or mining shares?

IMG Auteur
Published : December 18th, 2012
404 words - Reading time : 1 - 1 minutes
( 3 votes, 1/5 )
Print article
  Article Comments Comment this article Rating All Articles  
Our Newsletter...
Category : Investing





There are many reasons to own physical gold. They arise from the financial and monetary uncertainty impacting investors around the globe. Some of the more obvious reasons are:

*       Weakening economic activity and rising inflationary pressures bring back unpleasant memories of the stagflation experienced in the 1970s

*       Geopolitical tensions remain a major area of focus

*       The ongoing sovereign debt crisis and the knock-on effect it is having on the solvency of some of the world’s largest banks because they own too much government paper


By owning physical gold you are protected from the above because physical metal does not have counterparty risk. But do you also want to own the shares of gold mining companies? There are two things that need to be considered to answer this question.

The first is will the mining shares do well if gold appreciates? The answer is maybe. Normally the shares of gold mining companies appreciate at least as much as the price of gold, and sometimes do even better. But it does not always work out that way.

For example, from 2001-to-2011 gold has appreciated 14.5% per annum over these 11 years in terms of euros, and 17.7% per annum when gold’s price appreciation is measured in terms of US dollars. Over this same period, the Philadelphia Stock Exchange Gold and Silver Index, which in North America is a widely followed measure of gold mining companies, appreciated 3.2% per annum. Even when taking dividends into account, the mining shares over this period of time did not appreciate as much as the gold price.

Over the last 11 years, the shares of gold mining companies have on the whole done all right, and have in fact fared better than the general stock market. Clearly though, the shares have underperformed gold. The reason is that the shares of gold mining companies respond to circumstances differently than the price of gold, which leads to the second and more important point that needs to be considered.

The shares of gold mining companies are not a safe haven like physical gold. Gold does not have a balance sheet, management team, price/earnings ratio or any of the other things that characterise the shares of mining companies. This observation makes it clear that gold and mining shares are fundamentally different, meaning that the mining shares may not be suitable for everyone. Their risks need to be carefully studied, as is the case with any investment.



<< Previous article
Rate : Average :1 (3 votes)
>> Next article
James Turk is the founder of the Free Gold Money Report and of He is also the co-author of The Coming Collapse of the Dollar (
WebsiteSubscribe to his services
Latest comment posted for this article
Be the first to comment
Add your comment
Top articles
Latest Comments
Gold and Silver Update
29 Sepjustatrader
Hi Florian, good analysis. But don't you think have a stop at 1120 would be detrimental to the longer term upside bias? It is a great level of supp...
Congress and the Fed Refuse to L...
29 Sepsonora691
Great idea!! Audit the Fed, and while we're at it, let's get someone to audit the gold vaults in Fort Knox and at the Federal Reserve's gold storag...
In Defense of Gold
29 Sepsonora69
In 1933, President Roosevelt outlawed the ownership or possession of monetary gold by any US individual, partnership, association or corp...
29 Sepsonora69
In 1933, President Roosevelt outlawed the ownership or possession of monetary gold by any US individual, partnership, association or corp...
Gold and Silver Update
28 Sepjustatrader
In hindsight i feel stupid for exiting at 1150 from 1125. I like your bold statement but i think a dip to 1100 is likely... im watching that level ...
BEWARE: What If This Retail Silv...
25 Sepovertheedge
I only gave you three stars and here is why. "However, the important factor to understand is that most investors go after the WELL KNOWN produc...
Gold Daily and Silver Weekly Cha...
25 Sepjustatrader1
Hi Jesee, I came across this site from Zeal LLC and stumbled upon your blog (don't see anywhere to comment so i'm back here). Anyways, just a t...
Bull Trap or Bottom in Gold and ...
24 Sepneville
Just who the hell do think you are byrne....I heard the balderdash you sprouted on the kitco website with that woman cambone.....and it is con...
Most commented articlesFavoritesMore...
World PM Newsflow
Mining Company News
Prb Energy(Oil)PRB
Stock Market Update ...
US$ 24.61+0.07%Trend Power :
Corporate news
Consumers Energy, Grand Valley State University Break Ground on State's Largest Community Solar Project
US$ 35.61+1.95%Trend Power :
Corporate news
Victory Nickel(Ni-Pa)NI.TO
Victory Nickel Granted Extension for Delisting Review by the TSX
CA$ 0.02+0.00%Trend Power :
Corporate news
Piedmont Natural Gas' John Monaghan Awarded N.C.'s Order of the Long Leaf Pine
US$ 40.63+1.52%Trend Power :
Corporate news
Timmins Gold(Au-Ag)TMM.TO
Timmins Gold Reports Small Tear In New Leach Pads
CA$ 0.34+1.47%Trend Power :
Corporate news
National Fuel Gas Co.(Oil)NFG
Winter Heating Season Bills in Western New York will be the Lowest in 14 Years
US$ 51.06+2.37%Trend Power :
Corporate news
Atmos EnergyATO
Zacks Industry Outlook Highlights: Edison International, Atmos Energy, Consolidated Edison and WGL Holdings
US$ 58.93+1.92%Trend Power :
Corporate news
Prb Energy(Oil)PRB
How Does Cantel Medical Compare to Its Peers?
US$ 24.61+0.07%Trend Power :
Corporate news
Prb Energy(Oil)PRB
How Does Costco Compare to Its Peers?
US$ 24.61+0.07%Trend Power :
Corporate news
Victory Nickel(Ni-Pa)NI.TO
TSX Delisting Review - Victory Nickel Inc. (Symbol: NI)
CA$ 0.02+0.00%Trend Power :
Corporate news
Comments closed