Close X Cookies are necessary for the proper functioning of 24hGold.com. By continuing your navigation on our website, you are accepting the use of cookies.
To learn more about cookies ...
EnglishFrench
Gold & Silver Prices in

Ron Paul urges Arizona lawmakers to end capital gains tax on gold coins

IMG Auteur
Published : March 13th, 2017
633 words - Reading time : 1 - 2 minutes
( 0 vote, 0/5 )
Print article
  Article Comments Comment this article Rating All Articles  
0
Send
0
comment
Our Newsletter...

http://tucson.com/news/ron-paul-to-az-lawmake...gains-tax-on...

PHOENIX -- Invoking claims of illegally printed paper money, the use of gold in the Bible and even foreign entanglements, former Congressman Ron Paul urged Arizona lawmakers Wednesday to let coin collectors and investors escape the state's capital gains tax.

Paul, a three-time presidential hopeful, told members of the Senate Finance Committee it's not fair or even legal from his perspective for the government to take its share when someone who bought a coin at $300 later sells it for $1,200.


He said the value of the coin really remains the same. It's the value of that paper money -- money he contends is "fraud" -- that's gone down.

Paul's testimony helped buttress similar claims by Rep. Mark Finchem, R-Oro Valley, who already has ushered the tax break in HB 2014 through the House. The result was the Senate panel giving its OK on a 4-3 party-line vote and sending it to the full Senate.

But the real hurdle remains Republican Gov. Doug Ducey who vetoed similar measures in 2015 and again last year saying he feared the unintended consequences of such a change in tax law.

That isn't a unique concern. In 2013, Republican Jan Brewer also used her veto stamp.

"This would result in lost revenue to the state, while giving businesses that buy and sell collectible coins or currency originally authorized by Congress an unfair advantage," she wrote at the time.

That was exactly the complaint made Wednesday by Sen. Steve Farley, D-Tucson, in urging colleagues to kill the measure.

He said the legislation would make sense if a $20 gold piece sold for $20 in what most people recognize as legal currency. But what it sells for, Farley said, is based on a combination of the amount of precious metal, the condition of the coin and the demand for what might be a rare coin.

"So to give someone a capital gains tax break on the money they make ... from selling that coin seems like just simply a tax giveaway that other people would be paying for because we're going to need to get enough money to pay for our roads and schools anyway," Farley said.

"Why does the government need the money is the big question," Paul said. Anyway, he said, if the government needs money it should tax people "more honestly" than by making them pay capital gains for their efforts to protect themselves against inflation.

Farley, for his part, said the flaw in the arguments by supporters of the legislation is that somehow the type of investment decision should govern its tax liability.

"There's a lot of places people can decide to invest their money as a hedge against inflation," he said.

"You can invest it in stocks, you can invest it in real estate, your house, a lot of other things," Farley continued. "That also goes up in value over time and that represents, at least in some part, inflation."

The difference here, Farley said, is that people pay capital gains taxes when they sell a stock or any other investment for a profit; this bill creates a special exemption for gold and silver coins.

"So to me that's picking winners and losers," he told the former Texas congressman.

"I understand your point," Paul responded. "But the important point is stocks are not money and gold and silver are money."

And that goes to his contention that there's no legal basis for all this paper money out there.

"Congress is allowed to coin money," Paul said. "They don't have the authority to print money."

One thing the panel did not consider is what would be the cost to the state of such an exemption.

No one was able to provide a figure of the tax implications of such an exemption.

* * *

Data and Statistics for these countries : Georgia | All
Gold and Silver Prices for these countries : Georgia | All
<< Previous article
Rate : Average note :0 (0 vote)
>> Next article
Chris Powell is the secretary of the Gold Anti-Trust Action Committee (GATA) which has been organized to advocate and undertake litigation against illegal collusion to control the price and supply of gold and related financial securities.
WebsiteSubscribe to his services
Comment this article
>Follow all commentairies
You must be logged in to comment an article8000 characters max.
Log in or Sign up
Latest comment posted for this article
Be the first to comment
Add your comment
Top articles
MOST READ
How To Buy Gold Or Silver - Trace Mayer - Run to Gold  (10)
March 27, 1980 : Silver Thursday, or the end of the The Hunt Brothers Story - History of Silver - Playboy  (4)
The Bank of England 1720-1844 - Nathan Lewis - New World Economics
The Gold Bug (Edgar Allan Poe) - Treasures and Gold Fever - Edgar Allan Poe  (13)
Most commented articles More... 
TOP RATED
The Gold Bug (Edgar Allan Poe) - Treasures and Gold Fever - Edgar Allan Poe  (13)
The US Constitution and Money - Michael S. Rozeff - Mike S. Rozeff  (7)
How To Buy Gold Or Silver - Trace Mayer - Run to Gold  (10)
March 27, 1980 : Silver Thursday, or the end of the The Hunt Brothers Story - History of Silver - Playboy  (4)
Most commented articles More... 
MOST COMMENTED
100 Items That Disappear First in a Disaster - Beans Bullets Bullion and Bible - 24hgold  (17)
Most commented articles More... 
Latest Comments
‘Real’ Performance Comparison
26 MarChristopherbalz
Question: In the method of figuring inflation referenced, what is the rationale for adding population growth to productivity growth? Sugge...
100 Items That Disappear First in a Disaster
23 Markevthorne
68, 69 probably not that safe - particularly if you're growing your own vegetables - keep a Maine Coon cat instead: does the job automatically.
Farage Interviews Le Pen: “Prison of the EU”
21 Marneville1
BRITANNIA RULES THE WAVES AND NOW BREXIT WAIVES THE RULES. GO FOR IT FRANCE AND RID YOURSELVES FROM THE CHAINS OF IDIOTS. NOT SIN...
How the Fed Operates — And Why It's a Problem
20 Marramasart
In a nutshell, the Fed facilitates the theft of the value of the dollar, as they can control the increase in supply which at the same time inverts ...
How the Fed Operates — And Why It's a Problem
20 Marneville1
With all due respects for outlining how the crooked american Fed works or should work. From all our research we find the following the Fed...
Sparta - Gold prohibition in a collapsing economy
18 Markevthorne
You've answered none of the authors points: your comment is flat rubbish.
America Too Broke to Fix Crumbling Infrastructure? “Bridges, Roads,...
16 MarCameron Waugh1
Just like the leaders of the Bolshevik revolution were not Russians, those formulating belligerent US foreign policy are not Americans, and they ha...
POTUS at SOTUS
16 MarDRGEORGE1
Try explaining that to my patients dying on public waiting lists or getting ripped off by exorbitant private specialist fees!
Most commented articlesFavoritesMore...
World PM Newsflow
ALL
GOLD
SILVER
PGM & DIAMONDS
OIL & GAS
OTHER METALS