What is the difference between a recession and a depression? When your neighbor loses their job, it's a recession. When you lose your job, that's a depression!
But let's put the dry economic and not funny jokes aside. How to spot recession, without asking your neighbors about their situation at work? As we wrote in the March 2019 edition of the Market Overview, the two most reliable recessionary indicators are the yield curve and the unemployment rate (eventually, you may have to talk with your neighbors after all!). However, these are also not perfect. Many economists claim that the yield curve has lost some of its predictive power to the quantitative easing. Meanwhile, it's not easy to determine the trough in the unemployment rate in real time. How do we know whether the increase in the unemployment rate is the start of a new recessionary trend or just a temporary jump?
Well, economists to the rescue! Claudia Sahm, an economist at the Fed, has developed a new method for predicting economic downturns. In her chapter within the book Recession Ready: Fiscal Policies to Stabilize the American Economy, she develops an indicator based on the unemployment rate, but better. Sahm argues that economy is headed for recession, when the three-month average unemployment rate is at least 50 basis points above its minimum from the previous twelve months.
Why the three-month average is used? It smooths out some of the monthly random variation in the rate and avoids false positives. And why do we use moving average minimum? In contrast to a fixed unemployment rate threshold, this type of trigger takes into account structural changes over time in the natural rate of unemployment. Moreover, rapid increases are informative regardless of the level of the unemployment rate. Let's take a look!
Chart 1: Sahm's Index (the difference between the three-month average of unemployment rate and the minimum from the previous twelve months) from January 1970 to May 2019.
Wow, as the chart above shows, the mentioned index has correctly called every US recession since 1970. For instance, the indicator sent an alarm signal in January 2008, warning of the unfolding Great Recession.
What is more, the new indicator detected few, if any, false positives. It touched, but did not cross, 0.5 percentage point shortly in 1986 and 2003. It makes the Sahm's index really reliable.
However, the indicator is not perfect. Its Achilles heel is timeliness. For example, it flashed red in September 1990, two months after the official beginning of the recession. Similarly, the index rang a bell in July 2001, three months after the Nasdaq peaked and the dot-com bubble started bursting. It's a significant limitation - after all, anticipating recession is far more useful for investors than acknowledging that we are just experiencing one. For comparison, the yield curve's inversion signals a recession about four to six quarters before the recession starts.
But do not count this indicator out! After all, knowing that we are in a recession is also valuable. Remember that the NBER determine the official date ex post, several months after the start of the recession. And although the Sahm's index flashed red in January 2008, one month after the official start of recession, it signaled danger several months before the bankruptcy of the Lehman Brothers, when the worst started.
OK, so what is the index saying to us now? It tells us not to worry. The three-month average unemployment rate is just 0.1 percentage point above its minimum of the past twelve months. It implies that we are not in recession. And it suggests that the downturn might not be as imminent as widely believed. Based on the indicator, the chances of a recession occurring in the next twelve months is about 20-33 percent. After all, the Sahm's indicator stays at a very low level, and it is not rising toward the recessionary threshold.
That's is bad news for gold. The yellow metal perform best when the economy is steeped in a crisis. We are still not there, my bullish friends. However, remember that bullion tends to appreciate not only during recessions. Just look at the chart below: the 2000s bull market in gold coincided with Sahm's index well below the trigger level!
Chart 2: Sahm's Index (red line, left axis, the difference between the three-month average of unemployment rate and the minimum from the previous twelve months, in %) and the price of gold (yellow line, right axis, in $, London P.M. Fix) from January 1970 to May 2019.
And the Sahm's index has limited ability to spot the recession in advance. The yield curve has already inverted, so we cannot exclude that the new indicator will also flash red, but only later.
If you enjoyed the above analysis and would you like to know more about the expansions, recessions, and gold, we invite you to read the July Gold Market Overview report. If you're interested in the detailed price analysis and price projections with targets, we invite you to sign up for our Gold & Silver Trading Alerts. If you're not ready to subscribe yet and are not on our gold mailing list yet, we urge you to sign up. It's free and if you don't like it, you can easily unsubscribe. Sign up today!
Thank you.
Arkadiusz Sieron
Sunshine Profits' Gold News Monitor and Gold Market Overview Editor
