Tax Cuts Without Spending Cuts Won't Grow the Economy

IMG Auteur
 
Published : October 11th, 2017
632 words - Reading time : 1 - 2 minutes
( 1 vote, 5/5 )
Print article
  Article Comments Comment this article Rating All Articles  
0
Send
0
comment
Our Newsletter...
Category : Today's Article
24hGold - Tax Cuts Without Spe...

President Donald Trump proposed last month a tax plan that would lower the top individual tax rate to 35% from 39.6%. It would also lower the corporate income tax rate to 20% from 35%.

The plan however, says nothing about how spending will be cut to avoid increasing deficits. According to supply-side economics — a relatively new school of economics — a reduction of tax rates and lower revenues for the government does not need to be offset by decreased government spending or increased borrowings.

It is held that the boost in consumer spending and investment in capital goods will set the platform for a stronger economic growth, which in turn will lift government revenues and trim the budget deficit.

Effective tax depends on the size of the government outlays

The problem rests with the fact that the government is not a wealth generating entity as such — the more it spends, the more resources it has to take from wealth generators. What really counts is the amount of wealth diverted to government from wealth generators. 

Irrespective of the official lowering of tax rates, as long as government spending is not curtailed, there is not going to be an effective lowering of the government tax.

The government will always find ways to divert real wealth to itself. This could be achieved by means of printing money, increasing borrowings, or by imposing various levies. In the presence of a central bank, a lowering of tax rates — sans spending cuts — merely rearranges the way government diverts weath to itself. 

So what then are we to make out of President Trump’s plan of lowering tax rates?

It is quite likely that the initial response of consumers and businesses to the lower tax rates would be to boost their spending.

However, without a real cut in spending, the impression that market participants now have more wealth is illusory.  This results in the misallocation of resources.

Without the lowering in effective tax rates — achieved by lowering both spending and taxation — individuals would not lift their spending without the preceding increase in real wealth. What we have here is that more important market-guided priorities are denied the necessary funding in favor of government-spending activities that continue in spite of "tax cuts." 

This in turn means that the government’s faux lowering of taxes inflicts damage to the wealth generation process and curtails the potential economic growth.

No doubt — in terms of GDP — the lowering of the tax rates will appear to be a temporary success. This supposed success is likely because the increase in the money supply growth rate — which has a direct link to the so-called GDP growth rate — emerges to help the government to divert wealth to itself from wealth producers.

Note that real GDP is the amount of monetary expenditure on final goods and services — including government outlays — deflated by a dubious price deflator. Obviously, the stronger the monetary growth, the stronger the GDP growth rate.

We can conclude that a meaningful lowering of taxes can only emerge once the government has lowered its outlays in absolute terms. Once outlays are curtailed this will result in less wealth being diverted from wealth generators to the government.

Once more real wealth is made available to wealth producers, this strengthens the process of real wealth generation and sets the platform for stronger economic growth.

Contrary to what the followers of supply-side economics claim, it is not possible to strengthen economic growth by lowering the tax rates whilst keeping the size of government outlays intact.

What the followers of this type of economics suggest is that something can be created out of nothing. These followers confuse the GDP growth rate with the growth rate of the pool of real wealth.

Source : mises.org
Data and Statistics for these countries : Georgia | All
Gold and Silver Prices for these countries : Georgia | All
<< Previous article
Rate : Average note :5 (1 vote)
>> Next article
Frank Shostak's consulting firm, Applied Austrian School Economics, provides in-depth assessments and reports of financial markets and global economies.
Comments closed
Latest comment posted for this article
Be the first to comment
Add your comment
Top articles
Latest Comments
Silver Price Forecast 2019/2018: Silver Bull Market Is Almost Here
14 JulS W.
How can you sell at $60 if you've sold it all $30 What is your stop price $ It will not surprise me to see it go to $10 or $11 because...
The End of Quantitative Easing and Gold
09 JulRocco
Once the fed is done with the tightening cycle, what will happen from there? Will they just keep the fed rate at around 2.9% or will they keep rais...
Silver Price Forecast 2019/2018: Silver Bull Market Is Almost Here
09 JulRocco
100% for a safe profit investment. If it goes above $60 for sure i'm going out and selling ALL my silver to http://nycbullion.com ... I would even ...
Why Is Healthcare So Complex and Over-Priced in America?
03 JulRocco
Insurance companies keep raising the amount of the discount they receive from hospital bills and etc. Therefore hospitals and doctors keep raising ...
Silver Price Forecast 2019/2018: Silver Bull Market Is Almost Here
05 Julprljr
Good ??'s I was wondering the same things.
Silver Price Forecast 2019/2018: Silver Bull Market Is Almost Here
04 JulS W.
If the market ? goes bearish or bullish you have to ask yourself the question "why did I buy silver in the first place?" Do you have a stop? What i...
Silver Price Forecast 2019/2018: Silver Bull Market Is Almost Here
02 JulRocco
Great article, I think/hope silver will continue the bull!! I've invested in too much silver for it to start being a bearish market!
Why Is Healthcare So Complex and Over-Priced in America?
02 Julprljr
The AMA makes sure that their members always profit from their customers. Why do doctors need a union? Go back to before the AMA was created t...
Most commented articlesFavoritesMore...
World PM Newsflow
ALL
GOLD
SILVER
PGM & DIAMONDS
OIL & GAS
OTHER METALS