Institutional confidence is akin to gravity. We know it’s there, and we understand a lot about it - but we haven’t yet been able to explain it adequately enough. At least not enough to quantify its relationship - or unify gravity with the other physical forces that we do understand. Of course, we are much further from unification of the interactions between confidence (behavior), the economy, and finance.
It’s easy to see the effect finance has on the economy. One can even map the ultimate effect through history, which is riddled with failed currencies. Ultimately, the failure of an untethered financial system culminates with the collapse of a currency.
Just as gravity is crucial for keeping things from floating away, sound money is the force that is crucial for controlling the trajectory of modern financial policy.
Somewhere along the line, confidence pushes things over the edge, and the tipping point comes from a confluence of failures in faith.
This may be where we are now. When you hear people speak of “something afoot,” this is what they mean.
Of course, financial confidence is an abstract concept formed in the collective view--a view maintained by truly dangerous falsehoods.
We may not be able to unify confidence with the real economy and a financial system unhinged, but we can all come to appreciate its gradual thinning.
Note: Some people assume all finance is bad. I don’t. But I believe that a financial system should be rooted firmly to some physical reality. It should be fixed to a substance that can be easily valued, measured, and is free floating in the market place. What that literally looks like and how we could get there from here is another topic for another day.
Cracks of confidence can appear over broad stretches, in a variety of institutions that one may find quite surprising when looked at in the overall.
For example, a friend recently sent me a rant about the health care system. It went as follows:
“The Sick Care fiasco has so many problems that have metastasized over decades of abuse that I don’t know it can ever be fixed. Between pharmaceutical corporations, research universities, patent law, doctors, hospitals, FDA, CDC, and other government bodies, trade associations, insurance companies, psychiatry, medical coding, no-fault settlements, Hollywood, Wall Street, and the ignorant ‘just-give-me-a-pill’ consumer/patient - we are stuck in a downward spiral.”
I immediately wrote back with a quasi-MadLib to exhibit how easily the same could be said for other institutions. My version:
“The {Sick Care | financial system} fiasco has so many problems that have metastasized over decades of abuse that I don’t know it can ever be fixed. Between {pharmaceutical corporations | giant multinational banks}, {research universities | economics departments}, {patent law | zero prosecutions}, {doctors | HFT-dark pool exchanges}, {hospitals | agency revolving door}, {FDA | SEC | CFTC}, {CDC | Federal Reserve | Treasury | IMF | World Bank}, & other government bodies, trade associations, insurance companies, {psychiatry | general ignorance | mass propaganda}, {medical coding | financial reporting | fictional accounting standards GAAP}, {no-fault settlements | two-tiers of justice}, Hollywood, Wall Street, and the ignorant {‘just-give-me-a-pill’ | ‘just give me yield’} {consumer/patient | investor/Muppet} - we are stuck in a downward spiral.
Institutions are strong, cohesive sets of beliefs and expectations held in the collective mind.
Institutional confidence or “confidence” represents the great unquantifiable component of modern finance. It simply doesn’t fit into the equations, the risk profiles, the algorithms or the charts.
There will always be a few, however, who hang on to the conceptual idea, no matter how poorly the home team performs or how invasive they become.
The problem we face with institutional confidence is that the remaining fans have near absolute power — they can make things appear to be as they are not for an extended period of time.
These collective patterns may have made sense or might have worked at some point, but are now out of date. They are antiquated, afraid, and grasping for more and more power.
Here’s a list of institutions in order of confidence from a Gallup poll taken last year.
The Military
Small Biz
Police
The Church or Organized Religion
The Medical System
US Supreme Court
The Presidency
The Public Schools
Banks
The Criminal Justice System
Newspapers
Organized Labor
Big Business
News on the Internet
Television News
Congress
Military at the top, banking in the middle, and Congress at the bottom.
http://jlewisinc.net/TheFallofConfiden
