|
Forget
about juggling a basket of country risk in places like South Africa and South
America. For his money, newsletter writer John Kaiser would rather take a
chance on explorers in his own backyard of the western U.S., based on
millions of years of geology and some exciting new discovery methods. In this
exclusive interview with The Gold Report, Kaiser
outlines the trends, and the juniors staking their claims, in Nevada.
Companies Mentioned : Barrick Gold Corp. : Carlin Gold Corp. : Coeur
d'Alene Mines Corp. : Gold Standard Ventures Corp. : McEwen Mining Inc. : Nevada Exploration Inc. :
Newmont Mining Corp. : NuLegacy Gold Corp. : Rye Patch Gold Corp. : Spruce Ridge Resources Ltd.
Related Companies Allied Nevada Gold Corp. - Almaden Minerals Ltd. - Bullfrog Gold Corp. - Comstock Mining Inc. - Gold Canyon Resources Inc. - Pershing Gold Corp. - Southern Silver Exploration Corp.
·
The Gold
Report: John, 2012 has been a volatile year
for junior equities. What is your thesis for diversifying your portfolio to
both protect and possibly grow wealth in this market?
John
Kaiser: It's interesting that American
households currently have bank deposits totaling $8.7 trillion, which is an
all-time record, and yet these deposits are earning less than 1%. This
illustrates the anxiety about where the general economy and equity markets
are going. Given the risk that we could end up in a global recession next
year that could possibly deteriorate into a depression down the road, it is
understandable that the public wants to keep its capital secure.
This could
have very negative implications for the general equity markets, which are
vulnerable to all sorts of disruptions. That is why I am recommending that
cautious investors leave 90–95% of their portfolio in low-yielding cash
deposits and then shift the other 5–10% into a diversified portfolio of
extremely high-risk securities that could yield some big winners. The area
that I think is going to be very prospective in the next few years is
discovery exploration in the resource sector, where stocks can go up 10, 20
or 30 times in response to a discovery.
TGR: A lot of
the resource sector used to be focused on South Africa. That's becoming
riskier due to worker unrest. South America has had violence and
nationalization threats. Are there still opportunities in relatively safe
domestic markets like the U.S.?
JK: I think
we are ripe for a return of interest to the U.S. mining exploration and
development sector. It has been shunned to some degree because of long
permitting cycles, even for exploration programs. The timeline can be even
worse when it comes to putting a mine into production.
"The
area that I think is going to be very prospective in the next few years is
discovery exploration in the resource sector, where stocks can go up 10, 20
or 30 times in response to a discovery."
Fueling
this return will be a growing interest in raw material self-sufficiency, of
which the boom in shale oil and gas is an early example. In other parts of
the world such as South Africa, erupting social tensions threaten the
operations of major mines. In some countries, higher gold and copper prices
are leading to resource nationalism, increased demands for royalties from
governments that don't care if increased operating costs are whittling away
profits. These countries are losing their attractiveness as a place for
operating and developing mines, let alone exploring for new deposits. Others
such as China impose export quotas that create two-tier pricing systems that
favor China-based businesses.
TGR: You
recently toured the historic mining state of Nevada. What are the geological
factors that make that basin attractive as gold and silver targets? What are
the major trends there? How did they form?
JK: Nevada is
the second-largest gold-producing region in the world. Much of this comes
from the north-central part of Nevada where we have famous names like the
Carlin Trend and the Battle Mountain-Eureka Trend. This region has very
unusual geology where old sedimentary rocks have thrust over each other, with
an upper plate horizon consisting of fairly impermeable siltstones over a
more permeable limestone lower-plate sequence of rocks. This happened several
hundred million years ago.
Several
subsequent waves of magmatism and folding occurred
due to pressure from the west as island arcs crashed into Nevada and caused
buckling of the entire land mass. The subduction
slab underneath caused magmatic upwellings, which
created igneous intrusions and doming. The result is a very complex geology
that looks like a messed up sheet of bubble wrap.
Then,
about 40 million (M) years ago, the Pacific plate stopped crashing into the
North American continent and the Farallon subduction slab started to founder. As this slab failed
like a retreating Niagara Falls, it caused magmatic upwellings.
According to a new theory proposed by University of Reno's John Muntean, this spawned gold-rich vapors, also laden
arsenic, antimony, thallium and mercury that penetrated crustal cracks, mixed
with water and resulted in Carlin-style gold deposits where upper-plate
capped lower-plate rocks served as structural traps that soaked up the gold
and its marker elements like a sponge.
These
deposits can be very large, deep and offer high gold grade. Only about half
of Nevada's estimated gold bounty of more than 150 million ounces (Moz) has been found to date thanks to another subsequent
event. The other half is hidden because about 15M years ago, the pressure on
the continent ceased and Nevada stretched apart, causing long blocks of rock
to rise or fall, which created our basin and range topography. Because the
gold deposits already existed before this happened, some ended high, some ended deeper. With erosion, these basins filled, and
now they are largely gravel covered. A new wave of exploration could be
coming based on the bounty that remains to be found.
TGR: What are
some examples of explorers that are in a good position to find that bounty
and how are they doing it?
JK: The most
obvious strategy is to look within the apparent trends of known deposits.
This includes the Carlin Trend, the northern part of which is dominated by Newmont Mining Corp. (NEM:NYSE) and Barrick Gold Corp. (ABX:TSX; ABX:NYSE), which
own all the key land. At the southern end, Gold
Standard Ventures Corp. (GSV:TSX.V; GDVXF:OTCQX) has the
Railroad Gold project where it is using a clever reconstruction of the
geology to home in on what it believes to be a significant Carlin-style
deposit.
"Nevada
is the second-largest gold-producing region in the world."
Within the
Battle Mountain-Eureka Trend is the more recently famous Cortez Trend, which
started in the 1990s with the Pipeline discovery, which is now being mined by
Barrick. Then, at the start of this century, Cortez
Hills was discovered within a few miles of Pipeline. Now we're seeing that
the Cortez Hills Trend is extending to the Gold Rush and Red Hill deposits.
More than 7 Moz has been added to the 20 Moz at Cortez in addition to the 25–30 Moz at Pipeline. The juniors control most of the southern
part of this trend. McEwen Mining Inc. (MUX:NYSE;
MUX:TSX) assembled a very large land package
during the last decade and spent nearly $60M exploring without coming up with
any significant, lower plate-hosted, Carlin-style deposits, which just shows
you how difficult it can be.
Now
another round of companies is coming in to turn over the rocks in this
historic area. NuLegacy Gold Corp. (NUG:TSX.V) assembled
several properties a couple years ago when everybody was in a funk about gold
exploration and the company is now in the process of drilling what it calls
the Red Hill property. This is a lower-plate window, which is exposed. It has
been drilled with shallow holes in the past that have intersected gold
mineralization that is not rich enough to make a mine, but NuLegacy figures that if it follows that statigraphy deeper, it will find the richer and longer
intersections needed to put together a deposit.
Another
company that is in the area is Carlin Gold
Corp. (CGD.TSX.V), which has just finished drilling a half-dozen holes on its Cortez Summit, which is just to
the east of the Gold Rush deposit. Again, a lot of this is blind drilling.
It's expensive. In new target areas you don't really know what's happening in
the third dimension, so your first round of drilling is all about just getting
the geology to see where you are and then the geologists can start to think
where the deposit would be.
Rye Patch
Gold Corp. (RPM:TSX.V; RPMGF:OTCQX) is another
company that managed to pick up the Garden Gate Pass project when a company
let it lapse, and it also optioned into the Patty project, which was part of
the McEwen Mining project. It has a major drill program on the Garden Gate,
where it is going to drill several deep core holes. It hopes that it hits the
target mineralization, but the real goal is to understand how the geology
behaves on trend with the main deposits. The same is true on the Patty
project, where it has some gold mineralization from past drilling, but it is
trying to sort out where the system is going.
"The
key thing is to understand what the company thinks it is going to
accomplish."
One of the
new developments that just emerged this week is Nevada Exploration Inc.'s
(NGE:TSX.V) Grass Valley, Nevada, project, which
was generated by an innovative technique called hydrogeochemistry
that focuses on the gravel covered basins of Nevada. Groundwater is collected
and tested for gold and all the various poisons, such as arsenic, antimony,
thallium and mercury, which are normally associated with Carlin-style
deposits. Where tests show a gold-in-groundwater anomaly, geologists can take
a closer look at the bedrock underneath.
The
interesting thing about the Grass Valley anomaly is that instead of striking
northwest-southeast as is the norm within the Cortez Trend, the Grass Valley
anomaly strikes southwest-northeast. This play is stunning because although
it is within eyesight of the Cortez Hills deposit, it's in a geological
setting where no one would think of wasting any money to explore. Yet, this
new technique pointed to an anomaly that shows a 10- to 15-mile strike, a
linear anomaly, likely associated with a hidden fault that appears to host an
oxidizing gold deposit that is the source of the full set of Carlin-style
elements.
McEwen
Mining has elected to earn 70% by carrying the prospect generator 30% to a
production decision. This is a high-stakes play, which could make a big
difference for McEwen Mining itself, which is also developing a number of
smaller deposits in Mexico and at the southern end of the Cortez Trend.
TGR: Unlike
the Grass Valley project, the Gold Standard, NuLegacy,
Carlin and Rye Patch projects are based on trends that are already known to
exist because they are home to working mines. Is that correct?
JK: Yes. They
are looking for these lower-plate windows within the primary trends where the
mineralization is close enough to surface to be found and commercially
exploited.
TGR: Are we
talking about open-pit mines or are these deeper than that?
JK: If they
are near surface, they can be open-pit mined. Cortez Hills is part open-pit
and part underground mine. Finding a new
near-surface deposit in the outcropping part of Nevada is going to be
difficult. You need to look in an area where there's a very thin veneer of
upper-plate rocks and somebody correctly guesses that mineralized lower-plate
rocks are just beneath 50–100 meters (m) of waste rock that can be stripped
off to allow an open-pit mine.
In the
basins, where you're typically looking at 100m or more of gravel, it may be
more difficult to create an open-pit mine, so the targets need a richer high
grade and size where you have 0.3 ounce or better gold mineralization to make
underground mining profitable. Another issue is that the deeper you go, the
more likely the mineralization will be refractory, which has a higher
processing cost.
TGR: A lot of
these areas have been looked at before, maybe in the 1980s when the price of
gold was less. Where are we in the current discovery cycle? How long do
investors have to wait before some of these pay off?
JK: The easy
gold has already been found in Nevada. Now we have had a decade or so of
fairly sophisticated exploration looking for lower-plate windows. The next
wave will require a very sophisticated search similar to what is happening at
Rye Patch and NuLegacy, or a very innovative
exploration strategy like hydrogeochemical
sampling. The beauty of the latter is that it results in new discoveries such
as Grass Valley where no one would have a prior geological reason to explore
in the first place.
An example
of this is another project called Fletcher Junction that Nevada Exploration
has optioned to a tiny junior called Spruce Ridge
Resources Ltd. (SHL:TSX.V) in the
Walker Lane Trend in the western part of Nevada. It is in the Aurora
district, which has produced about 4 or 5 Moz
during its lifetime from gold and silver epithermal veins.
In this
case, we are looking at an area covered by a very young volcano. The lavas
are not very thick, but they have covered a fairly large area. Nevada
Exploration Inc. collected hydrogeochemical samples
on the edges of this lava flow and found gold in the groundwater emanating
from underneath this lava cap. It drilled some shallow, reverse-circulation
holes to confirm the depth of the bedrock several years ago. Now the farm-in
junior is bringing more expensive, angled core drilling designed to
demonstrate what could be another Comstock Lode-type system. Comstock, which
produced 8 Moz gold and 200 Moz
silver, was found because its veins were exposed in outcrop. The early
prospectors could not see what was under the Aurora lava flow, and modern
explorers had no reason to drill through the lava.
Companies
are moving back into old districts within the Walker Lane that were last
explored in the 1980s, applying what they learned from the Ken Snyder mine in
Northern Nevada that turned out to be a very high-grade, bonanza-type vein
system and figuring out where to drill new holes. The Comstock, itself, was
mined out during the 19th century, and now the lower-grade material left
behind is being put back into production as a heap-leach gold mine. I see the
Walker Lane undergoing a revival of exploration interest from the juniors.
TGR: On the
Cortez Trend, what are the juniors learning from what Newmont and Barrick are finding in their mining operations that will
make finding the next one easier?
JK: They have
learned the structural and stratigraphic controls for this mineralization. Barrick will give a couple of important papers in the
next 12 months about what makes the Cortez Hills system tick. Everyone is
eager to learn the secrets because this helps them guide their own drilling.
It's very rare that miners come up with a target using remote-sensing methods
such as geophysical surveys or geochemical surveys and then spear the primary
deposit with the first few drill holes.
With Pipeline,
numerous holes were drilled before the primary deposit was found, and even
then, it was found because NuLegacy's Roger Steininger drilled a condemnation hole twice as deep as
he was supposed to for a heap-leach pad for the smaller Gold Acres deposit.
An understanding of the geology and the mineral controls can guide the
exploration process, which literally is a feedback-driven process of
underground groping. That is why these are high-risk endeavors and junior
valuations are relatively low. That is also why you can get 10, 20 and
30-fold price increases when an exploration discovery is made and the market
recognizes it as the real thing.
One way
juniors can protect themselves is by always having a plan B ready to tackle
if plan A starts to look as if it is not going to deliver the goods.
TGR: It sounds
as if that is what McEwen, NuLegacy and Rye Patch
have. They all talk about a number of other targets on the map.
JK: That's
right. Rye Patch's big story right now is the Rochester litigation. Last year
Coeur d'Alene Mines Corp. (CDM:TSX; CDE:NYSE) let all
of its Bureau of Land Management claims lapse. Rye Patch noticed that these
claims were open and staked them, covering a good part of the existing
resource that Coeur d'Alene had developed. If a judge agrees that even though
Coeur d'Alene didn't pay its fees, it doesn't matter because it has an
established mine, it gets to keep it.
If Coeur
d'Alene loses that case, it will have to do a deal with Rye Patch to acquire
the claims. One way that this could end up being a win-win for everybody is
if Coeur d'Alene buys Rye Patch's properties in the Oreana
Trend, including the disputed claims, it would end up with a strategic land
position that includes Lincoln Hill adjacent to Rochester. Either way, right
now Rye Patch has a higher valuation than the typical junior undertaking
grassroots exploration because it has this dual strategy of Oreana Trend/Rochester while it is drilling deep holes in
the Cortez Trend, hoping to find something that makes the company worth $1 or
$2 billion.
TGR: That
takes us back to your thesis in the very beginning. If 10% of our portfolio
is in the high-risk exploration resource sector, how much could it return?
JK: The way
the junior exploration market works is we have these deep, cyclical troughs
and high peaks. Right now, we are in a cyclical trough. There has been little
appetite for discovery exploration in the past decade. The glass is half
empty. No one expects any junior to get lucky, which is why we have very low
valuations. If one of them makes a major discovery, say NuLegacy
goes from $0.16 to $3 or $4/share, that's a 20 or 30-fold increase.
So if you
have a $10,000 diversified portfolio of 10 juniors while $90,000 sits in
savings deposits, and one of the juniors on which you risked $1,000 goes up
20 fold because of a discovery, then your portfolio consists of $90,000 cash
and $30,000 in high-risk high-reward juniors, in effect a 20% return on the
entire $100,000 portfolio.
If the
discovery has been recognized as a substantial new development, then the
market starts to look at these other juniors and says, wow, the glass is
actually half full, and we get a market upswing where the tide lifts all the
other boats as valuations of all companies in the area become more
optimistic. Right now, valuations reflect deep pessimism, not just about the
juniors themselves, but also about the overall global economic outlook.
I know
there are market cycles, such as in 2008 when we had a catastrophic decline
that took down everything and severely hurt that 10% of my portfolio that's
in extremely high-risk stocks. However, that also produced very, very low
valuations. So I simply rethought everything. I carved a bit of that 90%
parked in cash earning nothing, which had become 98%, reallocated it so that
10% was exposed to resource juniors bottom fished at
extremely low bargain prices.
Since
Q1/11 we have had a similar decline, which is why I published a new
bottom-fish edition in July consisting of 100 of these high risk, high reward
juniors. The trick is to make sure when your high-risk portfolio blossoms in
value that you restore capital back to the 90% of the cash portion of your
portfolio. Thus if we get another meltdown that so many fear is imminent, my
downside is restricted to 10%.
Because I
avoid revenue producing companies I don't have to worry about things such as
how many iPhones Apple is going to sell and what the latest patent lawsuit is
going to do. I don't worry about anything but these little juniors and what
their projects are. You do have to put some effort into understanding how the
exploration sector works. Otherwise, you're just making random guesses. But
it is possible to do this because we have all these resources now available
on the Internet.
TGR: Any final
advice for investing in the western basin based on the trends you're seeing?
JK: The key
thing is to understand what the company thinks it's going to accomplish. If
it simply tells you that it is going to find something big, give it a pass.
If it shows you detailed diagrams of its various data sets and extrapolations
of what it thinks is represented by the target, then you know that when it
spends your money drilling that target, there is a chance that it will
deliver something. Avoid the companies that do not have well-developed and
data-supported targets. And finally, it's very entertaining to track these
juniors in my portfolio.
TGR: Thank you
for your time, John.
JK: Thank
you.

See the
Visual Capitalist's infographic on mining in
Nevada:
John Kaiser, a mining
analyst with 25-plus years of experience, produces Kaiser Research Online.
After graduating from the University of British Columbia in 1982, he joined
Continental Carlisle Douglas as a research assistant. Six years later, he
moved to Pacific International Securities as research director and also
became a registered investment adviser. He moved to the U.S. with his family
in 1994.
Want to
read more exclusive Gold Report interviews like this? Sign up for our
free e-newsletter, and you'll learn when new articles have been published. To
see a list of recent interviews with industry analysts and commentators,
visit our Exclusive Interviews page.
DISCLOSURE:
1) JT Long of The Gold Report conducted this interview. She personally
and/or her family own shares of the following companies mentioned in this
interview: None.
2) The following companies mentioned in the interview are sponsors of The
Gold Report: Rye Patch Gold Corp. and Gold Standard Ventures Corp.
Streetwise Reports does not accept stock in exchange
for services. Interviews are edited for clarity.
3) John Kaiser: I personally and/or my family own shares of the following
companies mentioned in this interview: Rye Patch Gold Corp., Nevada
Exploration Inc. and Spruce Ridge Resources Ltd. I personally and/or my
family am paid by the following companies mentioned
in this interview: None. I was not paid by Streetwise Reports for
participating in this interview.
|