*
*
*
Mémoriser
Mot de passe oublié ?
Se connecter
Créer un compte gratuit
Se connecter avec Facebook
Fermer X
Les cookies sont necessaires au bon fonctionnement de 24hGold.com. En poursuivant votre navigation sur notre site, vous acceptez leur utilisation.
Pour en savoir plus sur les cookies...
Anglais
Francais
Abonnement
Connexion
Mot, article, auteur
Compagnie, symbole
Une mine, un projet
Pièce Or, lingot
Pièce Argent, lingot
Cours Or & Argent en
Choisissez
Chinois
Hindi
Anglais
Espagnol
Arabe
Thai
Francais
Allemand
FORUM
L'or et l'Argent monnaie
Politique, Euro, Europe
Ca fait du bien d'en parler...
L'Or et l'Argent physique
Ebay, leboncoin, les brocantes
Les actions minières
Les Analyses Techniques
L'Or et l'Argent papier
La numismatique
Economie - Bourse - Immobilier
Reflexion à partager
Orfèvrerie et Argenterie
Annonces diverses
Manipulation du prix de l'Or
Les bons plans
Les bonnes adresses
24hGold
NEWSFLOW MONDIAL
Tous
Or
Argent
Cuivre
Zinc
PGM & Diamants
Autres métaux
Pétrole et Gaz
Uranium
Sociétés Minières
OR & ARGENT PHYSIQUE
Cours Or et Argent
Comparateur Achat / Vente
Carte des professionnels
Annuaire des professionnels
Pièces d'Or par pays
Assistant Ebay pour l'Or
Liste des Pièces en Or
Pièces d'Argent par pays
Assistant Ebay pour l'Argent
Liste des Pièces en Argent
Simulateur Achat d'Or
ACTIONS MINIERES
Profils des Sociétés
Reserves, Ressources et métaux
Projets, propriétés et mines
Production
Analyse technique
Dernières découvertes
Newsflow Actions Minières
TrendPower des minières
STATISTIQUES
Statistiques par Pays
Statistiques par Métal
Métaux Précieux dans 159 monnaies
Cours des métaux
Or et Argent industriels
Indices des marchés
UNIVERSITE DE L'OR
Abécédaire des Idées Fondamentales
Essais sur l'Or et l'Argent
Abécédaire de l'Or
Analystes et Contributeurs
Commentateurs
Derniers commentaires postés
OUTILS
Convertisseur Or et Argent
Générateurs de graphiques
Nissab et Zakat en Français
Nissab et Zakat en Arabe
Rss
PRATIQUE
Publicité
Abonnez-vous
Contactez-nous
A propos de 24hGold
Articles
NewsFlow
La Cote de l’or et de l’argent
Market Briefing
Recevez notre Marketbriefing
vox kadavergehorsamkeit
Membre depuis mai 2012
222 commentaires
-
suivi par 1 personne
1 abonnées
A laissé un commentaire sur l'article :
Mind the Theory
- Thorsten Polleit -
i had read A. E. before and did read the piece you sent along. It has done nothing to change my mind whatsoever. That there is "almost a universal opposition to Austrianism" as stated in the article should tell you something. And what it should tell you is that a priori knowledge in the field of economics is utterly and completely impossible. Things that can be understood in such a fashion are few and far between and are never a matter for dispute. (A key point.) No one has doubts as to their own existence. A.E. is fine in other regards and i have no disagreements with it. But this nonsense that its precepts can be understood in an a priori fashion is doubtlessly a major reason why there is such opposition to it. This intransigent resistance by Austrians to such an obvious truth makes it seem more like a cult than anything else. Without experiment there is no science, for that is how theory is validated or disproved. Which leads to my next point. Economics is really a pseudo science in that with conditions always in flux, no test can ever be repeated. Conditions may be similar, but never the same. We can only make progress toward discovering what works best in this or any other field of study by studying what has gone before us, analyizing it and making changes to the theory as required; perhaps even abandoning it altogether in favor of another.
Think of it this way: a person who has spent their entire life living in a cave without any human contact would know with absolute certainty that he is alive. That is an example of a priori knowledge. That same person in the same situation would not be able to grasp the concept of a business cycle or deduce that gold works better than paper as a unit of account because he would have had no experience of such things.
Your statement that economics is an a priori science does not make it so. It is a dogmatic statement completely lacking in proof. Which of course it must be, for there is no gedanken experiment that can be undertaken by our cave dweller that would lead him to know with the same certainty he has that he is alive that there is a business cycle. Once you understand that, you can begin to use your own critical faculties to think for yourself; always employing your b.s. detector to steer clear of the pure, unadulterated nonsense that ideologues and messianic types try to bamboozle us with.
In the words of Jerry Rubin: Ideology is a brain disease.
Commenté
il y a 4282 jours
Tweet
-
envoyer
Début de l'article :
I. The saying that things may work nicely in theory, but do not necessarily work in practice is well known.[1] It is typically meant to disparage the importance of theory, suggesting it would be too far removed from practical matters to help in solving the issue at hand. The Prussian philosopher Immanuel Kant (1724–1804), in his 1793 essay "On the Popular Judgment: 'This May Be True in Theory, But It Does Not Apply in Practice,'" responded to such criticism; in fact, he responded with his essay to criticism leveled against his ethical theory by the philosopher ChristianGarve (1742–1798)...
Lire la suite
Répondre à ce commentaire
Vous devez être connecté pour commenter un article
8000
caractères max.
connectez-vous ou inscrivez-vous
Dernier commentaire publié pour cet article
chers Vladi,il est lor, oui, effectivement, et alors ? un fonctionnaire crée de la richesse ? creuser des trous crée de la richesse ? si nous arrêtions, pour voir, de payer nos impôts, vos 55, fonctionnaires compris, font quoi fin du mois ? merci d'expl
Lire la suite
ferzi
- 20/04/2013 à 20:03 GMT
Note :
1
3
Top articles
LES PLUS LUS
Valérie Hayer est visiblement nulle.
-
H. Seize
-
Hashtable
Articles les plus commentés
Plus...
Services
Nos flux RSS
24hGold Mobile
Gold Data Center
Convertisseur Or Argent
Pièces d'or sur eBay
Pièces d'argent sur eBay
Minières :
outils techniques
Minières : outils
d'analyse fondamentale