First Majestic Receives Positive Judgment for US$89.6 in Court Litigation
Published : April 26, 2013
( 0 vote, 0/5 ) Print article
  Article Comments Comment this article Rating Follow Company  
0
Send
0
comment

VANCOUVER, BRITISH COLUMBIA--(Marketwired - April 26, 2013) - FIRST MAJESTIC SILVER CORP. (News - Market indicators)(NYSE:AG)(FRANKFURT:FMV) (the "Company" or "First Majestic") is pleased to announce that on April 24, 2013, after a lengthy trial, the Supreme Court of British Columbia ruled in favour of First Majestic with respect to the previously reported litigation against Hector Davila Santos ("Hector Davila") (not related to the Company's Chief Operating Officer, Ramon Davila) and Minera Arroyo Del Agua, S.A. de C.V. (which subsequently became Minerales y Minas Mexicana, S.A. de C.V.).

In November 2007, the Company and its wholly-owned subsidiary, First Silver Reserve Inc. ("FSR") commenced an action against Hector Davila, the previous director, President & Chief Executive Officer of FSR. The Company alleged, among other things, that while Hector Davila held the positions of director, President and Chief Executive Officer of FSR, he violated his fiduciary duty to FSR and that subsequently, through Minera Arroyo, he acquired the Bolaños Mine from Grupo Mexico ("Grupo") for his own personal interest. FSR became a wholly owned subsidiary of First Majestic in September 2006.

The Honourable Mr. Justice Myers concluded that the Bolaños opportunity belonged to FSR and that Hector Davila did in fact breach his fiduciary duty by acquiring the Bolaños Mine. Mr. Justice Myers calculated in his ruling a net opportunity loss in favour of First Majestic in the amount of US$89.6 million, after reducing an initial amount of US$111 million for the post-acquisition investments of Hector Davila at the Bolaños Mine and applying a 15% reduction contingency. The US$89.6 million judgment does not include pre-judgment interest or legal costs, of which a portion is recoverable, nor has the court ruled on Hector Davila's counterclaim for, among other things, interest charges on the approximately CDN$14.250 million which has been held in Hector Davila's lawyer's trust account since July 2009. These issues, together with other outstanding issues, will be subsequently addressed by Mr. Justice Myers on a date to be scheduled. Under British Columbia law, Hector Davila has 30 days to appeal the April 24, 2013 judgment.

The Reasons for Judgment can be viewed on the Company's web site at www.firstmajestic.com/s/RelatedArticles until May 30, 2013. Significant excerpts from the 100 page judgment include the following:

  • "For the reasons that follow, I conclude that the Bolaños opportunity belonged to First Silver and that Mr. (Hector) Davila breached the fiduciary duty he owed to First Silver".
     
  • "Mr. (Hector) Davila had a great deal of knowledge about Bolaños because of his prior ownership of it. First Silver was entitled to the benefit of that knowledge, especially since Mr. (Hector) Davila saw fit to have First Silver pursue it. It was not up to him to unilaterally decide to take it for himself".
     
  • "The only conclusion that can be reached on this evidence is that Mr. (Hector) Davila breached his fiduciary duty to First Silver by sending the April 4th (2006) letter…"
     
  • "Factually, I do not think there was a shared assumption regarding Bolaños. Mr. (Hector) Davila did not assume that it was his opportunity; rather, he knew it was First Silver's. The following excerpt from his evidence is sufficient to show that:
  Q: So at the moment you meet with Ramon Davila at the time that meeting begins on April 3rd, 2006, it's First Silver that has the option to acquire the Bolanos property, not Hector Davila Santos personally; correct?
  A: Correct, sir.
  Q And if -- and if you had not said anything at all about Bolanos on April 3rd, 2006, if First Majestic became the majority owner of First Silver one of the things that would be acquired, as insofar as it was the majority owner, was FSR's option to pursue the Bolanos property; correct?
  A: Correct, sir.
  Q: So you'll agree with me that when you -- you agree with me that when you met with Ramon Davila on April 3rd, 2006, its First Silver's option, not Hector Davila Santos personally; correct? We've already talked about that?
  A: Okay. Yes, sir".
  • "Turning to Mr. Neumeyer, up to the time of the closing of the share purchase agreement, he did not believe or assume that Bolaños was not First Silver's opportunity. His suspicions were raised and he intended to investigate the matter further. And if he did mistakenly believe that the opportunity was Mr. (Hector) Davila's personally, this arose in whole or in part from Mr. (Hector) Davila having misrepresented that this was so. It cannot be the case that a defendant can raise an equitable defence based on his own misconduct".
     
  • "Further, the conclusion I reach from all of the evidence is that Mr. (Hector) Davila deliberately took advantage of the sale of his shares to obfuscate the dealings for Bolaños. He did this so that if First Majestic did not buy his tailings, he could then acquire Bolaños for himself under cover of the fog that inevitably occurs in a major corporate transition".
     
  • "I assessed the loss of First Silver at $105.4 million… Applying the 15% contingency to that results in a compensation figure of US$89.6 million".

Keith Neumeyer, President and CEO of First Majestic, states: "We are obviously very pleased with the ruling of US$89.6 million in our favour from the BC Supreme Court. It has long been my belief that the actions of Hector Davila in early 2006, when we purchased the majority interest in FSR, were inappropriate. After a lengthy, time consuming, expensive and difficult legal process, it is gratifying to have the BC Supreme Court agree with our arguments and grant us such a large award. However, I caution shareholders that, due to the magnitude of this award, we anticipate Hector Davila will appeal this decision and there will be further legal activities in order to realize this award. It is my view that directors and officers of public companies need to be held to the highest ethical and moral standards and should be role models for industry, to assure transparency and honesty for the benefit of all the stakeholders. I would like to personally thank our legal team headed by Shapray Cramer LLP who endured countless hours over the past five years diligently presenting and arguing our case which culminated finally in a 58 day trial resulting in this outcome."

First Majestic is a producing silver company focused on silver production in México and is aggressively pursuing its business plan of becoming a senior silver producer through the development of its existing mineral property assets and the pursuit through acquisition of additional mineral assets which contribute to the Company achieving its aggressive corporate growth objectives.

FIRST MAJESTIC SILVER CORP.

Keith Neumeyer, President & CEO

SPECIAL NOTE REGARDING FORWARD-LOOKING INFORMATION

This news release includes certain "Forward-Looking Statements" within the meaning of the United States Private Securities Litigation

Reform Act of 1995 and applicable Canadian securities laws. When used in this news release, the words "anticipate", "believe", "estimate", "expect", "target", "plan", "forecast", "may", "schedule" and similar words or expressions, identify forward-looking statements or information. These forward-looking statements or information relate to, among other things: additional court proceedings and the dates thereof, and recovery of judgment amounts.

These statements reflect the Company's current views with respect to future events and are necessarily based upon a number of assumptions and estimates that, while considered reasonable by the Company, are inherently subject to significant business, economic, competitive, political and social uncertainties and contingencies. Many factors, both known and unknown, could cause actual results, performance or achievements to be materially different from the results, performance or achievements that are or may be expressed or implied by such forward-looking statements or information and the Company has made assumptions and estimates based on or related to many of these factors. Such factors include, without limitation: availability of time on court calendars in Canada and elsewhere; the recognition of Canadian judgments under Mexican law; the possibility of settlement discussions; the risk of appeal of judgment; and the insufficiency of the defendant's assets to satisfy the judgment amount.

Investors are cautioned against attributing undue certainty to forward-looking statements or information. Although the Company has attempted to identify important factors that could cause actual results to differ materially, there may be other factors that cause results not to be anticipated, estimated or intended. The Company does not intend, and does not assume any obligation, to update these forward-looking statements or information to reflect changes in assumptions or changes in circumstances or any other events affecting such statements or information, other than as required by applicable law.



First Majestic Silver Corp.
Keith Neumeyer
President & CEO
(604) 688-3033 or Toll Free: 1-866-529-2807
(604) 639-8873 (FAX)
info@firstmajestic.com
www.firstmajestic.com
Data and Statistics for these countries : Canada | Mexico | All
Gold and Silver Prices for these countries : Canada | Mexico | All

First Majestic Silver Corp.

PRODUCER
CODE : FR.TO
ISIN : CA32076R1029
CUSIP : 32076R1029
Follow and Invest
Add to watch list Add to your portfolio Add or edit a note
Add Alert Add to Watchlists Add to Portfolio Add Note
ProfileMarket
Indicators
VALUE :
Projects & res.
Press
releases
Annual
report
RISK :
Asset profile
Contact Cpy

First Majestic is a silver producing company based in Canada.

First Majestic produces silver, gold, lead and zinc in Mexico, and holds various exploration projects in Canada and in Mexico.

Its main assets in production are LA PARRILLA SILVER MINE, LA ENCANTADA (FIRST MAJESTIC SILVER), SAN MARTIN and LA ENCANTADA SILVER MINE in Mexico and its main exploration properties are REAL DE CATORCE, DEL TORO and CUITABOCA in Mexico and PITT ISLAND, PINCOURT, DOMPIERRE and DESJARDINS in Canada.

First Majestic is listed in Canada, in Germany and in United States of America. Its market capitalisation is CA$ 1.5 billions as of today (US$ 1.1 billions, € 1.1 billions).

Its stock quote reached its lowest recent point on November 02, 2001 at CA$ 0.01, and its highest recent level on December 22, 2017 at CA$ 9.99.

First Majestic has 164 340 000 shares outstanding.

Your feedback is appreciated, please leave a comment or rate this article.
Rate : Average note :0 (0 vote) View Top rated
 
In the News and Medias of First Majestic Silver Corp.
8/13/2018First Majestic shares hammered after reporting $40 million-l...
1/21/2009Follow up N° 1
Annual reports of First Majestic Silver Corp.
Files Form 40-F Annual Report
2008 Annual report
2007 Annual Report
Financings of First Majestic Silver Corp.
8/20/2009Tranche of Non-Brokered Private Placement Closes
8/12/2009Non-Brokered Private Placement and Debt Settlement
Nominations of First Majestic Silver Corp.
4/4/2014Appoints VP of Technical Services
12/24/2013Announces Retirement of Robert Young from Board of Directors
1/5/2012Appoints Chief Information Officer
12/30/2011Names Douglas Penrose as Chairman
Financials of First Majestic Silver Corp.
2/25/2016First Majestic Announces Financial Results for Q4 and Year E...
2/3/2014Fourth Quarter and Year End Financial Results to be Released...
11/12/2013Reports Third Quarter Financial Results
10/31/2013Third Quarter Financial Results to be Released on November 1...
7/15/2013Second Quarter Financial Results to be Released on August 13...
5/15/2013Reports First Quarter Earnings of $26.5 million on Revenues ...
5/7/2013Quarter Financial Results to be Released on May 15th
11/14/2012Earns $24.9M in Third Quarter; Revenues of $63.6M, an Increa...
11/7/2012Third Quarter Financial Results to Be Released on November 1...
8/7/2012Second Quarter Financial Results to be Released on August 14...
5/10/2012Reports Strong Earnings of $26.4M in Q1 2012, Up 10% Compare...
5/4/2012First Quarter Financial Results to Be Released on May 10th
3/5/2012Announces New Record Earnings & Cash Flows for 2011
2/24/2012to Announce Fourth Quarter and Year End 2011 Financial Resul...
10/26/2011Third Quarter Financial Results to be Released on November 9...
8/3/2011Second Quarter Financial Results to be Released on August 11...
5/17/2011Earns a Record $23.9 million in First Quarter of 2011
5/11/2011Quarter Financial Results to Be Released on May 16, 2011-Con...
3/1/20112010 Audited Financial Results show Record Earnings & Cash F...
3/23/2010Year End & Fourth Quarter Financial Results
11/12/2009Record Third Quarter Financial Results
8/14/2009Second Quarter Financial Results
8/15/2008Second Quarter Financial Results
5/16/2008CORRECTION- MISSING TEXT - Record First Quarter Financial Re...
4/18/20082007 Year End Financial Results
Project news of First Majestic Silver Corp.
1/14/2014becomes a Senior Silver Producer; Produces 10.64M Ounces of ...
12/4/2013(Del Toro)Dor=E9 Production Commences at the Del Toro SilverMine
4/9/2013(Del Toro)Del Toro Silver Mine Flotation Circuit Deemed Commercial
1/9/2013Achieved Record Production of 2.6M Silver Eqv. Ounces (2.3M ...
9/27/2012Mine Videos - Just Released
1/24/2012(Del Toro)-La Parrilla Mill Expansion to 2,000 tpd Completed: Del Toro...
1/12/2012Achieved Record Production of 1.96M Silver Ounces (2.1M Silv...
10/13/2011(La Parrilla Silver Mine)Announces Q3 Production Results and Commences Commercial Pro...
9/22/2011(La Parrilla Silver Mine)First Stage of Expansion at the La Parrilla Processing Plant...
9/13/2011(La Parrilla Silver Mine)Mill Capacity at La Parrilla to Reach 2,000 tpd Following Po...
3/1/2011(San Martin)2010 Audited Financial Results show Record Earnings & Cash F...
4/8/2010(La Encantada (first Majestic Silver))La Encantada Achieves Commercial Production
11/26/2009(La Encantada (first Majestic Silver))La Encantada Opening Ceremony & Production of First Silver P...
10/13/2009(La Encantada (first Majestic Silver))La Encantada Expansion Nearing Completion
10/6/2009Third Quarter Production Results
2/17/2009(La Parrilla Silver Mine)La Parrilla Silver Mine Updates NI 43-101 Resource
1/20/2009(San Martin)San Martin Updated NI 43-101 Report Increasing Reserves/Reso...
7/17/2008(San Juan Silver Mine)Major Intersection At San Juan Silver Mine Drill Hole Inters...
4/29/20081st Quarter Production Results
4/23/2008(San Martin Silver Mine)Commissioning of Flotation Circuit at the San Martin Silver ...
4/1/2008(La Parrilla Silver Mine)Discovery of New High Grade Ore Shoot on the Vacas Vein at t...
1/8/2008(La Encantada Silver Mine)La Encantada Silver Mine Update and New NI 43-101 Resource
7/2/2007(La Parrilla Silver Mine)La Parilla Technical Report
Corporate news of First Majestic Silver Corp.
7/27/2016Coverage Initiated on Silver Stocks First Majestic Silver, S...
7/25/2016Second Quarter Financial Results to be Released on August 10
7/20/2016Here’s Why These Five Stocks Are on the Move on Wednesday
7/12/2016First Majestic Produces 4.7 Million Silver Eqv. Ounces in Se...
1/29/2016Silver Could Spike $10 In A Day In Global Collapse Scenario
11/28/2015How Top Traders Are Shifting Western Asst High Incm Opprtnty...
10/14/2015First Majestic Produces 3.6 Million Silver Eqv. Ounces in Q3...
10/14/2015First Majestic Produces 3.6 Million Silver Eqv. Ounces in Q3...
10/13/2015A Silver Lining in October 2015?
10/2/2015First Majestic Completes Acquisition of Silvercrest
10/1/2015First Majestic Completes Acquisition of SilverCrest
9/25/2015First Majestic and SilverCrest Announce Shareholder Approval...
9/15/2015Leading Independent Advisory Firms ISS and Glass Lewis Recom...
8/27/2015First Majestic and SilverCrest Announce Receipt of Interim O...
8/27/2015First Majestic and SilverCrest Announce Receipt of Interim O...
8/11/2015First Majestic reports 2Q loss
8/11/2015First Majestic Reports Second Quarter Financial Results and ...
8/10/2015Why Earnings Season Could Be Great for First Majestic Silver...
7/30/2015Second Quarter Financial Results to be Released on August 11
7/30/2015First Majestic Silver: Second Quarter Financial Results to B...
7/27/2015First Majestic Announces Friendly Acquisition of Silvercrest...
7/27/2015announces friendly acquisition of Silvercrest Mines
7/9/2015First Majestic Produces 3.8 Million Silver Eqv. Ounces in Q2...
4/23/2015NYSE stocks posting largest percentage decreases
4/23/2015First Quarter Financial Results to be Released on May 7
4/23/2015First Majestic Silver Corp. First Quarter Financial Results ...
4/22/2015First Majestic Silver Corp. Announces Closing of C$30 Millio...
4/20/2015NYSE stocks posting largest percentage decreases
4/13/2015NYSE stocks posting largest percentage decreases
4/13/2015First Majestic Produces 3.9 Million Silver Eqv. Ounces in Q1...
4/9/2015NYSE stocks posting largest percentage decreases
4/6/2015First Majestic Silver Corp. Announces C$30 Million Bought De...
4/6/2015Announces C$30 Million Bought Deal Financing
4/6/2015First Majestic Announces Promotion of Martin Palacios to Chi...
4/6/2015First Majestic Announces Acquisition of Shares of First Mini...
4/1/2015NYSE stocks posting largest percentage increases
4/1/2015First Majestic Updates Mineral Reserve and Resource Estimate...
3/31/2015Announces New La Guitarra NI 43-101 Technical Report
3/31/2015First Majestic Announces New La Guitarra NI 43-101 Technical...
3/11/2015First Majestic Renews Share Repurchase Program
3/11/2015First Majestic Renews Share Repurchase Program
8/22/2014to List on the Mexican Stock Exchange
10/24/2013Appeal Against First Majestic Dismissed
9/30/2013Applies to Dismiss Appeal of Positive Judgment for US$93.84 ...
7/10/2013Produces a New Quarterly Record of 3.27 Million Silver Eqv. ...
7/2/2013Payment of CDN$14.85 million Received in Court Litigation
5/2/2013Announces Completion of La Guitarra's Expansion to 500 tpd
4/26/2013Receives Positive Judgment for US$89.6 in Court Litigation
4/17/2013Earns Socially Responsible Business Distinction Award for Fi...
4/15/2013Produces Another Quarterly Record 2.73 Million Silver Eqv. O...
3/11/2013Announces Share Repurchase Program
2/19/2013Elects Not to Exercise Right to Match Coeur's Offer for Orko
2/14/2013Considering Superior Offer from Coeur to Acquire Orko Silver
1/25/2013(Del Toro)Production Commences at the Del Toro Silver Mine
10/10/2012Produces a Record 2.44 Million Silver Equivalent Ounces in T...
9/26/2012New Look! New Features! First Majestic Bullion Store
9/6/2012Keith Neumeyer's Interview With Minesite.com
8/27/2012Announces Appointment of VP of Exploration
8/21/2012(Del Toro)Updated Del Toro NI 43-101 Technical Report & Final Permit R...
8/16/2012Recognized as a Leader in Corporate Social Responsibility
7/17/2012Produces 2.1 Million Silver Equivalent Ounces in Second Quar...
7/3/2012Completes Acquisition of Silvermex Resources
6/26/2012mex Securityholders Approve Plan of Arrangement With First M...
5/22/2012(Del Toro)Del Toro NI 43-101 Technical Report & Pre-Feasibility Study
4/16/2012First Quarter Production Results and Full Commencement of Co...
4/3/2012Announces Friendly Acquisition of Silvermex Resources
3/30/2012Files Form 40-F Annual Report
10/7/2011Third Quarter Production Results to Be Released on October 1...
8/11/2011Record Earnings of $30.6 million in Second Quarter
7/7/2011Another Record Quarter of Silver Production
4/8/2011Silver Production Up 25%; Reaches 97% Pure Silver and Mainta...
8/16/2010Record Earnings and Cash Flows. Purest Silver Producer with ...
4/22/20102nd Year Running for Mexican Distinction as a "Socially Resp...
4/12/2010Production Increases by 30% to 1,619,403 Equivalent Ounces S...
1/12/2010Production Increases by 18%, Reaches New Record
11/13/2009Completes Acquisition of Normabec Mining Resources; Normabec...
9/14/2009to Acquire Normabec Mining Resources
8/13/2009Joins OTCQX
6/26/2009offering for purchase 0.999 fine 1oz. silver rounds, and 5oz...
3/5/2009Closing of $21.2 Million Offering
11/19/2008Operations Update
9/11/2008Many Positive Developments Underway
7/15/20082nd Quarter Production Shows Continued Ramp-up
3/25/2008Closing of $45,475,000 Offering
1/17/2008Another Record Quarter of Silver Production
12/14/2007TSX Conditional Approval
12/5/2007Update on the Chalchihuites Group of Properties
Comments closed
 
Latest comment posted for this article
Be the first to comment
Add your comment
TORONTO (FR.TO)OTHER OTC (FRMSF)
9.39+4.33%
TORONTO
CA$ 9.39
04/23 15:20 0.390
4.33%
Prev close Open
9.00 8.89
Low High
8.75 9.41
Year l/h YTD var.
5.74 -  10.95 17.67%
52 week l/h 52 week var.
5.74 -  10.95 -3.40%
Volume 1 month var.
867,630 29.16%
24hGold TrendPower© : -17
Produces Lead - Silver - Zinc
Develops
Explores for Gold - Lead - Silver - Zinc
 
 
 
Analyse
Interactive chart Add to compare
Interactive
chart
Print Compare Export
Last updated on : 12/27/2010
You must be logged in to use the porfolio and watchlists (free)
Top Newsreleases
MOST READ
Annual variation
DateVariationHighLow
202423.72%
2023-32.71%9.9510.07
2022-23.32%9.9610.00
2021-13.88%30.7512.74
20209.63%9.8610.08
 
5 years chart
 
3 months chart
 
3 months volume chart
 
 
Mining Company News
Plymouth Minerals LTDPLH.AX
Plymouth Minerals Intersects Further High Grade Potash in Drilling at Banio Potash Project - Plannin
AU$ 0.12-8.00%Trend Power :
Santos(Ngas-Oil)STO.AX
announces expected non-cash impairment
AU$ 7.72-0.19%Trend Power :
Oceana Gold(Au)OGC.AX
RELEASES NEW TECHNICAL REPORT FOR THE HAILE GOLD MINE
AU$ 2.20+0.00%Trend Power :
Western Areas NL(Au-Ni-Pl)WSA.AX
Advance Notice - Full Year Results Conference Call
AU$ 3.86+0.00%Trend Power :
Canadian Zinc(Ag-Au-Cu)CZN.TO
Reports Financial Results for Q2 and Provides Project Updates
CA$ 0.12+4.55%Trend Power :
Stornoway Diamond(Gems-Au-Ur)SWY.TO
Second Quarter Results
CA$ 0.02+100.00%Trend Power :
McEwen Mining(Cu-Le-Zn)MUX
TO ACQUIRE BLACK FOX FROM PRIMERO=C2=A0
US$ 11.03+1.47%Trend Power :
Rentech(Coal-Ngas)RTK
Rentech Announces Results for Second Quarter 2017
US$ 0.20-12.28%Trend Power :
KEFIKEFI.L
Reduced Funding Requirement
GBX 0.55-0.90%Trend Power :
Lupaka Gold Corp.LPK.V
Lupaka Gold Receives First Tranche Under Amended Invicta Financing Agreement
CA$ 0.06-8.33%Trend Power :
Imperial(Ag-Au-Cu)III.TO
Closes Bridge Loan Financing
CA$ 2.48+4.20%Trend Power :
Guyana Goldfields(Cu-Zn-Pa)GUY.TO
Reports Second Quarter 2017 Results and Maintains Production Guidance
CA$ 1.84+0.00%Trend Power :
Lundin Mining(Ag-Au-Cu)LUN.TO
d Share Capital and Voting Rights for Lundin Mining
CA$ 15.17-3.93%Trend Power :
Canarc Res.(Au)CCM.TO
Canarc Reports High Grade Gold in Surface Rock Samples at Fondaway Canyon, Nevada
CA$ 0.24+2.08%Trend Power :
Havilah(Cu-Le-Zn)HAV.AX
Q A April 2017 Quarterly Report
AU$ 0.19+0.00%Trend Power :
Uranium Res.(Ur)URRE
Commences Lithium Exploration Drilling at the Columbus Basin Project
US$ 6.80-2.86%Trend Power :
Platinum Group Metals(Au-Cu-Gems)PTM.TO
Platinum Group Metals Ltd. Operational and Strategic Process ...
CA$ 1.82-2.15%Trend Power :
Devon Energy(Ngas-Oil)DVN
Announces $340 Million of Non-Core Asset Sales
US$ 52.62+0.93%Trend Power :
Precision Drilling(Oil)PD-UN.TO
Announces 2017Second Quarter Financial Results
CA$ 8.66-0.35%Trend Power :
Terramin(Ag-Au-Cu)TZN.AX
2nd Quarter Report
AU$ 0.04+5.88%Trend Power :