Companhia Vale Do Rio Doce

Published : April 08th, 2020

TURQUOISE HILL'S RESPONSE TO PENTWATER CIRCULAR REINFORCES NEED FOR EFFECTIVE MINORITY SHAREHOLDER REPRESENTATION ON TURQUOISE HILL BOARD (TSX:TRQ) (NYSE:TRQ)

( 0 vote, 0/5 ) Print article
  Article Comments Comment this article Rating Follow Company  
0
Send
0
comment

TURQUOISE HILL'S RESPONSE TO PENTWATER CIRCULAR REINFORCES NEED FOR EFFECTIVE MINORITY SHAREHOLDER REPRESENTATION ON TURQUOISE HILL BOARD (TSX:TRQ) (NYSE:TRQ)

NAPLES, Fla., April 08, 2020 (GLOBE NEWSWIRE) -- Pentwater Capital Management LP ("Pentwater"), a long-term supportive investor and the largest minority shareholder of Turquoise Hill Resources Ltd. ("Turquoise Hill" or the "Company") (TRQ.TO) (TRQ.TO), owning, together with its affiliates and associates, approximately 9.09% of the Company's issued and outstanding common shares, today responded to Turquoise Hill’s April 6, 2020 press release.

Pentwater believes that Turquoise Hill’s release not only fails adequately to address the important concerns voiced in Pentwater’s recently filed proxy circular, but is both misleading and inaccurate in its attempt to deflect accountability for the self-inflicted wounds that have been an overhang on the Company's otherwise world-class asset base away from the Company’s management team and board of directors (the "Board").

A fundamental problem here is that Rio Tinto plc. (NYSE:RIO:US)(LON:RIO:L)(ASX:RIO:AX) ("Rio" or "Rio Tinto") controls the nomination and election of the entire Board.  The directors serve at Rio's discretion and at the same time they are responsible for overseeing multi-billion dollar transactions between Rio and Turquoise Hill.  Pentwater seeks minority shareholder support in demanding effective minority shareholder representation on the Board, which is imperative to achieve appropriate oversight of the varied and conflicted financial transactions between Rio and Turquoise Hill.

Turquoise Hill’s press release states that its, “management and Board have the requisite experience and judgment to oversee the successful development of this world-class asset.”  The facts tell a different story.

  • Turquoise Hill’s limited resources directly contradict the Board’s assertionsPentwater believes that there are not many large-scale developments of any kind that can be overseen successfully with only five dedicated employees, let alone a highly technical underground block cave development of one of the largest known copper/gold deposits in the world. Yet that is the total number of full time Turquoise Hill employees tasked with overseeing Rio Tinto, as the project manager, along with the thousands of contractors and workers on the project.
     
  • Turquoise Hill’s reliance on Rio – which itself has limited pertinent experience – directly contradicts the Board’s assertions.  If the Turquoise Hill Board and management team have the requisite experience and judgment to oversee the successful development of this world class asset, why would they need to pay Rio to oversee development of a power plant despite Rio’s limited expertise in developing power plants?  Pentwater became alarmed last year upon learning that Rio Tinto requested “several hundred million dollars of fees for managing and overseeing the construction of the Tavan Tolgoi power plant.”  Pentwater wrote a letter1to the Board at the time voicing its concerns. To this day, shareholders have received no substantive disclosure or explanation from Turquoise Hill regarding Rio Tinto’s potential involvement in this project.  Turquoise Hill should explain to its shareholders what role Rio Tinto is slated to play in this project and how much it will be compensated. If Rio Tinto is in fact going to be paid to oversee the project, Turquoise Hill must explain why Rio Tinto was the best choice over and against other potential power-plant-construction oversight managers.

_________________________________
1 Please see the copy of the letter attached to the version of this press release filed on SEDAR.         

Also in its press release, Turquoise Hill states that it, “has retained independent third party experts to review cost and schedule reporting.”  Who are these supposed “experts” and what did they say?

  • If true, they are certainly not doing a good job.  On March 14, 2019, Turquoise Hill issued a press release which stated that it expected, “that project cost was expected to remain within the US$5.3 billion budget.”  Exactly four months later on July 15, 2019, Turquoise Hill issued another press release which stated that, “the development capital spend for the project may increase by US$1.2 to US$1.9 billion over the US$5.3 billion previously disclosed.”  Is it credible to believe that this board and management team are knowledgeable and in control when they go from reaffirming costs to disclosing a US$1.2 to US$1.9 billion budget overrun in four months?

  • If there are independent third-party experts who review costs, why won’t the Turquoise Hill board report that information to its shareholders?  Turquoise Hill stated in numerous filings that the final fit-out of Shaft 2 was scheduled to be completed by the end of 2018, reaffirming this timing as late as July of 2018, just 10 weeks prior to the announcement of material delays that would result in Shaft 2 being delayed a full year, until October of 2019.  How much of the delay was Rio’s fault?  How much did the delay of Shaft 2 contribute to the cost overruns?  Turquoise Hill refuses to share this information with its shareholders.

Turquoise Hill states that The Board “has a strong record of refreshment,” exemplified by the addition of two independent directors in the past three years.  “Refreshment” is an odd word for surprise resignations.

  • Turquoise Hill fails to mention that the reason the need arose for these two new directors to be added and for the Board to be “refreshed”, is the fact that the two independent directors who resigned in the past four years both resigned abruptly and outside of the regular board election process, with no new board members ready to replace them and without any publicly disclosed reason. One of the directors, James Gill, who had served on the Board for over five years and received the most votes in favour at Turquoise Hill's most recent annual general meeting, resigned just five days before Turquoise Hill first announced material cost overruns and delays at the Oyu Tolgoi Project on July 15, 2019. Despite repeated shareholder requests, no credible reason has been given for these abrupt resignations. Far from “refreshing,” such abrupt, mid-term, unexplained director resignations are very concerning.

Finally, Turquoise Hill states that the Board has implemented “a long-term TRQ stock-based incentive plan to align executives’ interests with those of all shareholders.”  The Board’s is aligned with Rio, period.

  • This statement belies reality. When the entirety of the executive team and the Board of Directors collectively own common shares worth less Cdn$151,000 based on current trading prices, the only shareholder with whom their interests are aligned is the majority shareholder that hired them and can at any moment fire them, Rio Tinto. Aside from the CEO, the largest holding by any member of the executive team or Board is the 30,000 shares held by the Board Chair Peter Gillin which are worth Cdn$18,600 based on current trading prices. To be clear, he owns Cdn$18,600 worth of shares after eight years of serving as an independent director.

Pentwater does not take lightly the idea of criticizing the management and corporate governance of any company in which it owns a significant equity stake. But Pentwater believes that a world-class asset deserves a world class Board that represents the interests of all shareholders, and not just the interests of its controller, Rio Tinto.  Pentwater believes that the right changes, if enacted swiftly at the upcoming shareholder meeting, will redound to the benefit of Turquoise Hill and its shareholders.

We Need Your Support

We are seeking your support at the Company's upcoming annual and special meeting of shareholders to be held on May 12, 2020 to restore accountability at Turquoise Hill, and give minority shareholders back their voice.

We encourage our fellow shareholders to consider the facts and take action against the current culture of entrenchment, value destruction and misconduct at Turquoise Hill. The interests of the Company's minority shareholders have been disregarded for far too long. Your vote is critical to initiate much-needed change, to restore accountability and to safeguard minority shareholder interests in Turquoise Hill.

Shareholders are urged to vote only the GOLD proxy:

  • FOR the election of Matthew Halbower to the board of directors of the Company;
     
  • WITHHOLD in respect of the election of all of the management nominees to the board of directors of the Company; and
     
  • FOR the adoption of the shareholder proposal submitted by Pentwater to amend the Company's articles to provide minority shareholders of the Company with the exclusive right to nominate and elect three of seven directors to the Board.

Shareholders are urged to read the full text of Pentwater's proxy circular, related press releases and the April 3, 2019 Letter to the Turquoise Hill Board, which are being filed and made available under Turquoise Hill's issuer profile at www.sedar.com.

For further information contact:

MacKenzie Partners, Inc.
Daniel Burch – 1-212-929-5748
Jeanne Carr – 1-917-648-4478
Email: SaveTRQ@mackenziepartners.com

About Pentwater

Pentwater is a private investment firm focused on investing in event driven strategies with expertise across the capital structure. Founded in April of 2007, the firm’s experienced team uses a dynamic, disciplined approach to mitigate risk and optimize returns.

The head office of Pentwater is located at 1001 10th Ave South, Suite 216, Naples, FL 34102.

Read the rest of the article at https:

Companhia Vale Do Rio Doce

PRODUCER
CODE : RIO
ISIN : US7672041008
Follow and Invest
Add to watch list Add to your portfolio Add or edit a note
Add Alert Add to Watchlists Add to Portfolio Add Note
ProfileMarket
Indicators
VALUE :
Projects & res.
Press
releases
Annual
report
RISK :
Asset profile
Contact Cpy

Vale do Rio is a copper producing company based in .

Vale do Rio produces copper, aluminum, bauxite, iron, manganese, nickel and silica in Brazil, develops coal and copper in Australia and in Brazil, and holds various exploration projects in Brazil and in Peru.

Its main assets in production are ALUNORTE, URUCUM MINE, MILTONIA 3, MORRO DA MINA, TAQUARI - VASSOURAS, SOSSEGO MINE, CAPAO XAVIER, CARAJAS, ANDRADE, SAMARCO, CONCEIÇÃO, MINAS DO MIEO, AGUA LIMPIA / CURURU, GONGO SOCO, BRUCUTU, BAU, FABRICA NOVA, FAZENDAO, TIMBOPEDA, CORREGO DO FEIJAO, SEGREDO/JOAO PEREIRA, PICO/SAPECADO/GALINHEIRO, VARGEM GRANDE COMPLEX TAMANDUA, CAPITAO DO MATO, ABOBORAS, PARAOPEBA COMPLEX JANGADA, SERRA NORTE - N4W, SERRA NORTE - N4E, SERRA NORTE - N5-W, SERRA NORTE - N5E, SERRA NORTE - N5E-N, SERRA NORTE - N5S, SERRA LESTE, MILTONIA 5 and MRN (BAUXITE MINING) in Brazil, its main assets in development are BELVEDERE in Australia and SALOBO PROJECT in Brazil and its main exploration properties are SALOBO, MAR AZUL MINE, ONÇA PUMA, PROJECT 118 and VERMELHO in Brazil and CORDILLERA DE LAS MINAS in Peru.

Your feedback is appreciated, please leave a comment or rate this article.
Rate : Average note :0 (0 vote) View Top rated
 
Nominations of Companhia Vale Do Rio Doce
12/18/2008appoints new president and CEO of Vale Inco
Project news of Companhia Vale Do Rio Doce
8/2/20167:25 am Rio Tinto approves development of Silvergrass mine t...
12/15/2015Rio Tinto CEO says high-cost iron ore miners squeezed by low...
Corporate news of Companhia Vale Do Rio Doce
8/3/20163:09 am Rio Tinto reports H1 results; earnings fall 45% YoY;...
8/3/2016Rio Tinto delivers strong cash flow generation of $3.2 billi...
1/30/2016Why the Grasberg Mine Is Crucial for Freeport-McMoRan’s 2016...
1/29/2016Talc: An Innocent White Powder
1/29/2016The Shark’s Still Circling
1/29/2016Rio Tinto’s Copper Lining
1/26/2016Commodity Prices to Affect Alcoa’s Upstream Performance in 2...
1/25/2016The Supply Side Doesn’t Have Good News for Iron Ore Prices i...
1/25/2016Rio’s Balance Sheet Could See It through the Cyclical Downtu...
1/25/2016Technical Coverage of Industrial Metals & Minerals Stocks --...
1/24/2016New Smelter to Keep Rio’s Aluminum Production Strong
1/22/2016How Are Rio’s Coal Volumes Expected to Progress in 2016?
1/21/2016Stocks Trading With Low PS Ratio, Wide Margin of Safety
1/21/2016Rio Reports Solid Q4 Operational Results on Higher Efficienc...
1/21/2016Will the Iron Ore Carnage Continue in 2016?
1/20/2016Rio’s Iron Ore Volume Guidance Might Have an Upside
1/6/2016Rio Tinto Slips to Strong Sell on Pricing Woes & Higher Cost...
1/4/2016Is the Tipping Point for Iron Ore Miners Getting Close?
12/30/2015Axiom Sees Rio Tinto's Dividend Policy As 'Unsustainable'; C...
12/29/2015Zacks Industry Outlook Highlights: Rio Tinto, BHP Billiton, ...
12/24/2015Zacks Industry Outlook Highlights: BHP Billiton, Rio Tinto, ...
12/23/2015Industrial Metals Stock Outlook - Jan 2016
12/21/2015Analyzing the Performance of Base Metal and Pure Gold Miners
12/18/2015Notable option activity in equities
12/18/2015Where Do Dividends Rank on Rio Tinto’s ‘Radar Screen’?
12/17/2015Miners Fell after the Interest Rate Hike but Recovered Later
12/1/2015Is Rio Tinto plc (ADR) (RIO) Going to Burn These Hedge Funds...
11/30/2015Smart Money Adores Priceline Group Inc (PCLN) More Than Ever
11/20/2015Court throws out claim that Vale and Steinmetz stole Rio Tin...
11/4/2015Why Aren’t BHP and RIO Cutting Copper Production?
11/3/20153Q15 Earnings Call: What Is Century Aluminum’s Strategic Pla...
11/3/2015Key Updates on Freeport-McMoRan’s Indonesia Operations
11/3/2015Can Alcoa’s Capacity Cuts Support Aluminum Prices?
11/2/2015What Can Cliffs Do to Weather the Industry Downturn?
10/30/2015Vale’s 3Q15 Results Were below Estimates, but Stock Rose
10/27/2015Buy into Mining Without Jumping on a Grenade
10/26/2015Are Glencore’s Leverage Ratios Getting Worrisome?
10/23/2015Rio Tinto: In-Line Aluminum, More-than-Expected Bauxite Prod...
10/21/2015Why Rio Tinto’s Kestrel Ramp-Up Keeps Coal Volumes Going
10/20/2015Why Rio Tinto’s Copper Production Could Have More Downside
10/20/2015Higher Q3 Iron Output Weighs on Rio Tinto and its ETFs
10/20/2015What Factors Are Driving Alcoa’s Performance?
10/19/2015Rio Tinto’s Iron Ore Volumes Continue to Deliver in 3Q15
10/19/2015Rio Tinto Delivers a Strong Set of Production Numbers for 3Q...
10/7/2015Rio Tinto’s Aluminum Production: Is There an Upside?
10/3/2015How Is Rio Tinto Trading Compared to Its Peers?
10/3/2015Rio Tinto’s Balance Sheet Seems to Be Under Control
10/1/2015Will Rio Tinto’s Growth Projects Lower Diamonds & Minerals C...
10/1/2015Will Rio Tinto Be Able to Deliver Further Cost-Cut Surprises...
9/30/2015Rio Tinto’s Iron Ore Division: Are More Cost Cuts Possible?
9/30/2015LME Aluminum Inventory Falls Even as On-Warrant Stocks Climb
9/30/2015How Falling Energy Prices Could Impact Aluminum Producers
9/29/2015China’s Weak Steel Production Outlook Will Hurt Iron Ore Min...
9/29/2015Why the Outlook on Iron Ore Is Still Negative
9/16/2015Rio Tinto Shows Good Growth Prospects, Risks Persist
8/21/2015Commodity Markets In Distress As Oil Rout Continues
8/19/2015How To Play Copper Long Term Amid A Low Prices Environment
8/12/2015Australian Dollar Plunges on Negative Sentiment
8/11/2015TAHOE RESOURCES REPORTS STRONG CASH FLOW IN Q2
8/11/2015Why Vale’s Financial Condition Is Deteriorating
8/11/2015What Led to Vale’s Increased Realized Iron Ore Prices in 2Q1...
8/11/2015How To Trade China's Surprise RMB Depreciation
8/10/2015Why Is the SPDR Gold Shares ETF (GLD) Losing Its Sheen?
8/10/2015Rio Reports Weak 1H 2015 Earnings on Mining Market Woes - An...
7/29/2015How are Cliffs’s Cost-Cutting Initiatives Progressing?
7/7/2015Iron Ore, Steel Falling And Taking The Sector With It
7/6/2015Why Cliffs Natural Resources Stock Price Is under Pressure
7/3/2015Iron Ore Price Slumps Big Time: Bad news for Rio Tinto? - An...
7/3/2015Which Iron Ore Companies Benefit from this Price Environment...
6/18/2015Weak Japanese Iron Ore Imports Are Negative for Iron Ore
6/17/2015Pressure Keeps Building on Miners ETFs
5/19/2015Breakthrough for Rio Tinto's $5.4b Mongolia Mine Expansion
4/21/2015Why Rio Reported Weaker-than-Expected Iron Ore Production in...
4/21/20156:26 am Rio Tinto announces a Q1 production update
4/16/2015Demerger Vote for BHP Billiton and South32 Is on May 6
4/15/2015Rio Tinto Pursuing 'Public Cloud First' Strategy for Corpora...
4/11/2015Will Steel Companies Benefit from Slide in Iron Ore Prices?
4/10/2015Iron Ore Prices Fall Below $50 Per Ton
4/1/2015Iron Ore's 10-Year Low Not Slowing China Production Push
7/7/2010Vale – 2Q10 Production Report
12/24/2008acquires coal assets in Colombia
12/16/2008to acquire exploration assets in the African copperbelt
12/8/2008reduces pellet production
12/4/2008announces adjustment in its nickel operations
11/21/2008JV adjusts production to market conditions
11/19/2008signs MOU with KEXIM
11/13/2008approves merger of MOP
11/7/2008Day in London
11/3/2008pays holders of mandatorily convertible notes
10/1/2008announces the date of 3Q08 results
9/30/2008signs leasing contract with Itabrasco
9/27/2008pays semi-annual remuneration on its Shareholder Debentures
9/26/2008On the effects of currency volatility
9/24/2008has approved bauxite and alumina projects
Comments closed
 
Latest comment posted for this article
Be the first to comment
Add your comment
NYSE (RIO)
62.91-0.02%
NYSE
US$ 62.91
09/18 17:00 -0.010
-0.02%
Prev close Open
62.92 63.32
Low High
62.84 63.88
Year l/h YTD var.
59.71 -  74.26 -15.28%
52 week l/h 52 week var.
59.71 -  74.77 -3.82%
Volume 1 month var.
1,936,205 0.688%
Produces Aluminum - Bauxite - Copper - Iron - Manganese - Nickel - Silica
Develops Coal - Copper
Explores for Copper - Gold - Iron - Nickel
 
 
 
Analyse
Interactive chart Add to compare
Interactive
chart
Print Compare Export
You must be logged in to use the porfolio and watchlists (free)
Top Newsreleases
MOST READ
Annual variation
DateVariationHighLow
2024-15.51%74.7260.05
20234.58%77.1158.28
20226.36%84.6950.92
2021-11.01%95.9759.58
202026.74%77.6435.84
 
5 years chart
 
3 months chart
 
3 months volume chart
 
 
Mining Company News
Plymouth Minerals LTDPLH.AX
Plymouth Minerals Intersects Further High Grade Potash in Drilling at Banio Potash Project - Plannin
AU$ 0.12-8.00%Trend Power :
Santos(Ngas-Oil)STO.AX
announces expected non-cash impairment
AU$ 7.07+0.28%Trend Power :
OceanaGold(Au)OGC.AX
RELEASES NEW TECHNICAL REPORT FOR THE HAILE GOLD MINE
AU$ 2.20+0.00%Trend Power :
Western Areas NL(Au-Ni-Pl)WSA.AX
Advance Notice - Full Year Results Conference Call
AU$ 3.86+0.00%Trend Power :
Canadian Zinc(Ag-Au-Cu)CZN.TO
Reports Financial Results for Q2 and Provides Project Updates
 0.12+4.55%Trend Power :
Stornoway Diamond(Gems-Au-Ur)SWY.TO
Second Quarter Results
CA$ 0.02+100.00%Trend Power :
McEwen Mining(Cu-Le-Zn)MUX
TO ACQUIRE BLACK FOX FROM PRIMERO=C2=A0
US$ 8.91-2.73%Trend Power :
Rentech(Coal-Ngas)RTK
Rentech Announces Results for Second Quarter 2017
US$ 0.20-12.28%Trend Power :
KEFIKEFI.L
Reduced Funding Requirement
GBX 0.59-3.26%Trend Power :
Lupaka Gold Corp.LPK.V
Lupaka Gold Receives First Tranche Under Amended Invicta Financing Agreement
CA$ 0.05+10.00%Trend Power :
Imperial(Ag-Au-Cu)III.TO
Closes Bridge Loan Financing
CA$ 2.06+0.00%Trend Power :
Guyana Goldfields(Cu-Zn-Pa)GUY.TO
Reports Second Quarter 2017 Results and Maintains Production Guidance
CA$ 1.84+0.00%Trend Power :
Lundin Mining(Ag-Au-Cu)LUN.TO
d Share Capital and Voting Rights for Lundin Mining
 12.67+0.88%Trend Power :
Canarc Res.(Au)CCM.TO
Canarc Reports High Grade Gold in Surface Rock Samples at Fondaway Canyon, Nevada
CA$ 0.34+6.25%Trend Power :
Havilah(Cu-Le-Zn)HAV.AX
Q A April 2017 Quarterly Report
AU$ 0.19+2.70%Trend Power :
Uranium Res.(Ur)URRE
Commences Lithium Exploration Drilling at the Columbus Basin Project
US$ 6.80-2.86%Trend Power :
Platinum Group Metals(Au-Cu-Gems)PTM.TO
Platinum Group Metals Ltd. Operational and Strategic Process ...
 1.77-2.21%Trend Power :
Devon Energy(Ngas-Oil)DVN
Announces $340 Million of Non-Core Asset Sales
US$ 40.37-0.22%Trend Power :
Precision Drilling(Oil)PD-UN.TO
Announces 2017Second Quarter Financial Results
CA$ 8.66-0.35%Trend Power :
Terramin(Ag-Au-Cu)TZN.AX
2nd Quarter Report
AU$ 0.04+0.00%Trend Power :
Take advantage of rising gold stocks
  • Subscribe to our weekly mining market briefing.
  • Receive our research reports on junior mining companies
    with the strongest potential
  • Free service, your email is safe
  • Limited offer, register now !
Go to website.