*
*
*
Remember
Forgot password ?
Connect
Register for a free account
Sign in with Facebook
Close X
Cookies are necessary for the proper functioning of 24hGold.com. By continuing your navigation on our website, you are accepting the use of cookies.
To learn more about cookies ...
English
French
Subscribe
Log in
Word, article or author
Company name, symbol
A mine, a project
Gold bullion
Silver bullion
Gold & Silver Prices in
Choose
Chinese
Hindi
English
Spain
Arabic
Thai
French
Deutch
FORUM
Gold and silver
Political, Dollar, USA
It's nice to talk about...
Physical Gold and Silver
Ebay, Amazon, Shop
Gold and Silver Mining
Technical Analysis
Gold and Silver currency
Numismatic
Economy - Stock - Property
Brainstorm
Gold and Silver ware
Announcement
Gold price handling
The best
The best places
24hGold
WORLD PM NEWSFLOW
All
Gold
Silver
Copper
Zinc
PGM & Diamonds
Other Metals
Oil and Gas
Uranium
Mining News
PHYSICAL GOLD & SILVER
Gold and Silver Data
Gold Bullion Prices
Ebay Gold Search Tool
Gold Coins Premiums
Silver Bullion Prices
Ebay Silver Search Tool
Silver Coins Premiums
RESOURCE STOCKS
Company profiles
Reserves and Resources
Projets, properties and mines
Production
Technical Analysys Tools
Latest Discoveries
Mining Stocks newsflow
Mining Stocks TrendPower
STATISTICS
Statistics by Country
Statistics by Metal
Precious Metal Price in 159 Currencies
Metal Prices
Market Indices
GOLD UNIVERSITY
Gold Essays
Analysts and Contributors
Commentators
Latest comments posted
TOOLS
Gold & Silver Converter
Graph Generator
Nissab and Zakat
Rss
USEFUL
Subscribe
Contact-us
About
Articles
NewsFlow
Gold & Silver Prices
Market Briefing
Recevez notre Marketbriefing
overtheedge
Member since May 2012
680 commentaries
-
6 followers
6 followers
has posted a comment on the article :
The Second Greatest Story Ever Told
- Antal E. Fekete -
Gold University
Well thought out argument, but it is based upon some erroneous assumptions.
"The unsurpassable naivety of this fable raises the question how serious students of money and credit have found it possible to treat it with respect. We should credit our ancestors with more intelligence and acuity than assuming that they fell so easy a victim to such a crude swindle, or that they meekly continue to be victimized long after the fraud has been exposed. "
The people of today readily accept fiat money, income tax, fractional reserve banking, credit cards, derivatives as investment vehicles, national inextinguishable debt and economic gurus. Either our ancestors had less intelligence and reasoning acuity or each succeeding generation leading up to us has suffered great loss of brain case capacity and/or brain function. We can assume that literacy rates are far higher now than 200, 500, or 2000 years ago. That puts your term of naivety in a far different light, no?
Here is the most probable reality.
#1 Fractional banking by goldsmiths actually was common. The fractional increase was probably less than 10%.
#2 Bills of exchange presume every buyer is a seller in a given marketplace. In fact merchants carried gold and hired guards as the caravans weren't just teamsters but traveling merchants as well. You would have each merchant transporting their goods to market in distant lands and transporting the traded for goods back to their home with no buying or selling along the way. Uh-huh, yah.
Consider the ship's captain of old. Not only was he tasked with transporting the ship's owner's goods, but also acted as the owner's selling and purchasing agent. Ever hear of the term "ship's purser"? And of course, these ships never carried real money; only letters of credit presumably?
Serious students should realize that the instructor tends to be intensely biased towards their own thesis. Things are far more complicated than any of us can imagine. Most myths and legends are based upon some historical occurrence. The day to day mundane never became a literary classic usable as a study in history of the marketplace.
"Second Greatest Story" tends to infer that you are a legend in your own mind. Perhaps that sells subscriptions. You have a lot of good arguments that make me sit down and think. Reality just ain't so simple or "cut and dried" as you would have us think. Were it so, it would be so self-evident that you would be redundant.
Still I rate it a 3.
Commented
3916 days ago
Tweet
-
Send
Beginning of the headline :
Fable has it that paper currency came into being as warehouse receipts issued by the goldsmith against gold left on deposit for safe-keeping. The owners found that they could make purchases with these warehouse receipts as easily as with gold coins. Then the goldsmith went on lending out at interest his fictitious warehouse receipts. According to this fable, the fraudulent business of the goldsmith in issuing warehouse receipts against non-existent gold was the embryonic form of the fractional-reserve banking of today...
Read More
Reply to this comment
You must be logged in to comment an article
8000
characters max.
Log in or Sign up
Dernier commentaire publié pour cet article
chers Vladi,il est lor, oui, effectivement, et alors ? un fonctionnaire crée de la richesse ? creuser des trous crée de la richesse ? si nous arrêtions, pour voir, de payer nos impôts, vos 55, fonctionnaires compris, font quoi fin du mois ? merci d'expl
Lire la suite
ferzi
- 20/04/2013 à 20:03 GMT
Note :
1
3
Top articles
MOST READ
Creatures of Unspeakable Horror
-
Jesse
-
Le Cafe Américain
Staggering Towards Another Minsky Moment - Hiding Out
-
Jesse
-
Le Cafe Américain
Through the Looking Glass: The Cult of Power
-
Jesse
-
Le Cafe Américain
Most commented articles
More...
Services
RSS feed
24hGold Mobile
Gold Data Center
Gold & Silver Converter
Gold coins on eBay
Silver coins on eBay
Technical Analysis
Fundamental Analysis