Close X Cookies are necessary for the proper functioning of By continuing your navigation on our website, you are accepting the use of cookies.
To learn more about cookies ...
In the same category

(angl) Why Does The "Paper Gold" Price Track The Physical Gold Price ?

IMG Auteur
Published : February 07th, 2013
770 words - Reading time : 1 - 3 minutes
( 4 votes, 3/5 ) , 6 commentaries
Print article
  Article Comments Comment this article Rating All Articles  
Our Newsletter...
Category : Editorials

It's curious, isn't it? So-called "paper gold" (a futures contract) has a price that is not only very close to physical gold, but it remains locked to it. This is despite the fact that "paper gold" is reviled in the gold community.

I am writing this on Sunday evening with little liquidity in the market, and yet spot gold (XAU) is 1665.80 and the December future (GC Z3) is 1674.40. There is a small positive spread, about 0.5%, between spot and future. This spread is remarkably consistent from day to day. If spot gold goes down 1.2% then the December future,and the other months as well, go down by almost exactly 1.2%.

It's worth underscoring that these are different prices for different things in different markets. "Paper gold" is not physical metal! If there weren't some force that kept their prices locked together, they would detach and one could rise while the other falls, or vice versa. This is not, in fact, how they behave. They remain locked (at least for the time being). Why? What is this mysterious force that binds them tightly together?

Let's take a step back for a moment. The futures market exists to serve the needs of producers and consumers. Producers -- miners in this case -- need to have predictable and consistent cash flow so they sell some of their production forward. Consumers, such as electronics manufacturers, and jewelers, have the same need so they buy some of their raw materials forward. Both can sign a contract now that locks in a price at some date in the future.

Of course, in the gold standard, there would be no such thing as a gold futures market. Futures for all other goods would be priced in terms of gold. Gold itself would not be available at a discount, nor would one ever need to pay a premium to get it. One could borrow it at interest, but that is in the bond market not in the futures market.

Once a futures market is established, speculators come in to bet on the direction of the price. They do not produce the good -- gold in this case -- nor use it. They cannot deliver gold to a buyer, nor do they wish to be delivered gold. They want to profit from a change in the price. They believe they have superior knowledge compared to the other market participants, and so use the futures market as an easier and more convenient way to bet than the physical metal market. And besides, the futures market offers leverage.

This is the basic theory of the futures markets, in a nutshell. Producers and consumers are trying to reduce risk. Speculators are making bets, pushing prices around, sometimes annoying the producers and sometimes annoying the consumers.

We still have not explained the fact that the price of "paper gold" tracks the price of gold metal. To do that, we need to introduce a third type of actor in the futures markets. The arbitrageur does not care about price; he is focused on spread. The arbitrageur can buy physical metal and at the same time sell a futures contract. This will earn him a little over $8 per ounce based on the prices I quoted at the top, or a bit more than 0.5% annualized. Compared to the yield on a 1-year Treasury, about 0.15%, this isn't bad.

So long as the price of the futures contract is higher than the price of the physical metal, then the arbitrageur can buy metal and sell a contract to pocket this spread. This will obviously lift the price of the metal and depress the price of the paper, compressing the spread. The arbitrageur will stop when the spread becomes too small to be worth his time, effort, and risk.

If the futures contract ever became cheaper than the physical metal (called "backwardation") then anyone who owns a gold bar can sell it and simultaneously buy a future with the intent to stand for delivery. In this case, the arbitrageur sells physical metal and buys a future, thus depressing the price of metal and lifting the price of the future. As in the previous case, the spread is compressed.

This is not merely academic theory. Analysis of this spread (called the "basis") can shed light on what's really happening in the markets. Sometimes (as now) there is a simple trade that is obvious, but only to someone looking at this spread.

In Part II of this article (free enrollment required for full access), we walk through the analysis and propose a contrarian precious metals trade.

Companies Mentionned : Gold | Metals X |
<< Previous article
Rate : Average note :3 (4 votes)
>> Next article
Keith Weiner is a technology entrepreneur and president of the Gold Standard Institute USA. He was the founder of DiamondWare, a Voice Over Internet Protocol software company, which he sold to Nortel in 2008. He is an Objectivist who has his PhD from the New Austrian School of Economics, with a focus on monetary science. Keith, who currently trades and analyzes precious metals and commodities, advocates a return to a proper gold standard and laissez-faire capitalism. He lives with his wife near Phoenix, Arizona.
Latest comment posted for this article
All games come to an end, and so does this one. Its demise was, indeed, encoded at the very time of the inception of the paper gold charade. Those worthless paper, never-to-exist ounces will be priced at their true value= $0; Physical Gold is re-set to i  Read more
Goldgirlme - 2/9/2013 at 12:49 PM GMT
Rating :  2  0
Top articles
Latest Comments
Gold Surges Another 7% This Week...
12 Febovertheedge
"Buyers should be getting into position to buy on the next dip." Gold is up something like 16% so far this year. Should'a bought when it wa...
Here We Go Again: Banks Are Impl...
12 Febsonora69
What is going to happen NEXT Monday? The Shanghai markets are closed all this week for the Lunar New Year. Monday morning ( or Sunday night U.S. t...
First Report since April, 2014
05 FebAndy_K1
Jason, One of your articles written way back is one of the reasons I started paying attention to silver and shortly thereafter started to ...
Something has Changed in Gold St...
06 Febneville
No nothing strange has happened in GOLD stocks....absolutely nothing.....The fact of the matter is that you byrne have been playing the man and...
The Revisionist Theory and Histo...
05 Febovertheedge
"The key is in the hand of the U.S. government. It is the same key that was used to lockthe U.S. Mint to silver in 1873, and to gold sixty years la...
First Report since April, 2014
05 FebS W.1
Here I was just 2 days ago thinking whatever happened to that evangelical silver guy. Low and behold up he springs, like some spirit from the g...
LBMA Silver “Price”: A Perfect S...
03 FebS W.
There is no doubt that the Comex can be used as a casino for those who want to trade Silver up/or down or maybe some just wish to take a small punt...
LBMA Silver “Price”: A Perfect S...
30 JanOzSILV1
Bron refuses to EVER admit this market is a Casino and the disconnect between Paper and Physical is a big clue to this
Most commented articlesFavoritesMore...
World PM Newsflow
Mining Company News
Lara Expl.(Cu-Zn-Au)LRA.V
Revised Resource Estimate Report Filed for Maravaia Copper Gold Deposit
CA$ 0.34+1.49%Trend Power :
Corporate news
Black HillsBKH
Black Hills reports 4Q loss
US$ 51.64-2.75%Trend Power :
Corporate news
Kinder Morgan(Oil)KMP
Midstream Companies Were above the 20-Day Moving Averages
US$ 102.03+1.98%Trend Power :
Corporate news
Kinder Morgan(Oil)KMP
Midstream Companies Were above the 20-Day Moving Averages
US$ 102.03+1.98%Trend Power :
Corporate news
Devon Energy(Ngas-Oil)DVN
Gasoline Inventories Rose Last Week despite Fall in Production
US$ 21.69+2.07%Trend Power :
Corporate news
United States Steel(Fe-Sn)X
U.S. Steel (X) States Ratification of Labor Agreements
US$ 7.40+8.35%Trend Power :
Corporate news
Black HillsBKH
4:34 pm Black Hills Corp beats by $0.04, misses on revs; guides FY16 EPS below consensus
US$ 51.64-2.75%Trend Power :
Corporate news
Black HillsBKH
Black Hills Corp. Reports 2015 Fourth Quarter and Full Year Results
US$ 51.64-2.75%Trend Power :
Corporate news
Transcanada PipelinesTRP.TO
TransCanada to Sign Substantial Agreement to Benefit Québec Economy
CA$ 48.65+0.16%Trend Power :
Corporate news
Devon Energy(Ngas-Oil)DVN
4Q15 Crude Oil Prices: Fallout for the Energy Sector and SPY
US$ 21.69+2.07%Trend Power :
Corporate news
Comments closed
  All Favorites Best Rated  
Why Does The "Paper Gold" Price Track The Physical Gold Price ?

It would be far more appropriate to switch this around. Why does the "Physical Gold" price track the Paper Gold price.

Now the answer is simple. The market is legalized gambling. There is little buying and holding physical compared to paper. Paper is far more convenient when it comes to trading, but we can make it easier still. It is all on the computer so no need to look for the paper either. There are vastly far more gamblers than producers and end users combined. HST ring a bell? Perhaps the house gets its bite?

If you don't know who the sucker is, it is you.

Rate :   1  2Rating :   -1
Yes, many are those buyers of never-to-exist "gold" (the paper,highly flammable variety) who are stunned that their purchase does not see the Comex 'gold' price advance!!! When supply can be made available at the tap of a few keys, shouldn't it be obvious to all but the most lumpen that they are missing something?!

Is it so hard to decipher that an endless supply of paper gold promises which can never be met -again produced with all the sweat of a tap here and a tap there- is a price CREATION tool. This stuff aint hard, is it? The Comex paper gold price, engineered by a limitless supply of BB paper gold, bears NO relation to the Physical Gold price. None. Behind the scenes, away from public view, the BIS shifts Physical to where its owners (of the BIS) have decided it will go. And the TRUE VALUE price is paid in these inter CB trades. There are people inside this machine, inside the dome. Preciousmetalspete has been there since 1978, and knows all the architects of the game. Check out his blogspot if you want to know how Gold works.

And the clues are blatant, smack in the face! The revelations are brazen if you have your eyes open.... e.g a 7 yr timescale required for the repatriation of a few measly tonnes from FRBNY to Buba?!... How come 7 years? How is that possible? Eyes-opening time!
Rate :   2  1Rating :   1
They have been playing with it for so many years that they wouldn't know how to get serious.
All games come to an end, and so does this one. Its demise was, indeed, encoded at the very time of the inception of the paper gold charade. Those worthless paper, never-to-exist ounces will be priced at their true value= $0; Physical Gold is re-set to its TRUE VALUE (a price which exists even today in inter CB Phys Gold trade).... The script unfolds precisely as described by preciousmetalspete in his blogspot article "How Oil is set to Reveal the ...True Value of Physical (and paper) Gold"... Using Iran's exclusion from the thieving USD as the kind of trigger which releases the encoded outcome, this is a seminal, much-read and highly-acclaimed article, which details the PROCESS of paper gold's burning and the PUBLIC revaluation of Phys Gold's true worth.
It includes also the rationale for the whole debt-fueled derivatives 'adventure'/theft and how such is washed away and balance restored. What happens to CB balance sheets with Phys Gold reset PUBLICLY to TRUE VALUE? They are repaired!! Wondered why such recent hefty CB Gold BULLION buying? Wondered why BULLION is being repatriated, 'all of a sudden'? The idea still advanced by the dinosaurs out there declaring that the world class store of wealth par excellence is comparable to a Comex-lie piece of toilet paper is utterly hilarious!
Rate :   2  0Rating :   2
Wow..... the unparalleled ignorance!

This is why the deceit continues; this is how the fraud continues. There is NO connection between paper gold and Physical Gold prices!! NONE! You are being sold an illusion, a magician's trick, which requires only that you BLINDLY accept the 'evidence' -more accurately, the 'show'- before your eyes in order to be misled. (Pssttt: the magician's assistant was not cut in half and put back together again)...

Why do you think such an outrageously minute amount of metal is available to the public at the fraudulent paper gold price? To cement the illusion in non-questioning minds!

Go and try to get your hands on any half-decent amount of Physical Gold; it will be an education for you.

There is no longer any excuse for the absurdly shallow and wholly misleading nonsense produced here. Gold market insider since 1978, preciousmetalspete at his blogspot, FOFOA, Turd, Brodsky, et al are producing analysis several billion light years ahead of this pure piffle found here.

To the uneducated who find any merit whatsoever in this article, I recommend they advance their thinking and post haste.
Rate :   2  1Rating :   1
To Goldgirlme
To tell you that Karandash gave you a thumb up.

re: wong tak says sorry (Jan Johnson)
Trade LYC with
Forum: ASX - By Stock (Back)
Code: LYC - LYNAS CORPORATION LIMITED ( 61.5c | Price Chart | $1,170.02M | Announcements | Google LYC)
Post: 9052524
Reply to: #9052514 from GC_Trekker Views: 238
Posted: 09/02/13 05:25 Stock Price (at time of posting): 61.5c Sentiment: Hold Disclosure: Stock Held From:

The Hotcopper message board. That's what I'd like to see on this message board. Every message gets a number. If you get a reaction you know whom it comes from. Do I care now whether I get 10 arrows down. I'd like to know who is behind them.

Post: 9052524
Reply to: #9052514 from GC_Trekker Views: 238