Close X Cookies are necessary for the proper functioning of 24hGold.com. By continuing your navigation on our website, you are accepting the use of cookies.
To learn more about cookies ...
EnglishFrench

Are Gold Miners Ready To Re-Open Hedge Books?

IMG Auteur
Published : May 02nd, 2013
952 words - Reading time : 2 - 3 minutes
( 2 votes, 1/5 ) , 1 commentary
Print article
  Article Comments Comment this article Rating All Articles  
0
Send
1
comment
Our Newsletter...

In 2009 news that Barrick Gold was going to close its hedge book to capitalize on what they projected were going to be higher gold prices.  It turned out to be a very bullish indicator that I wrote about here on this blog (and other blogs picked up on it as well). It was at a time when even I was projecting higher gold prices.  Let’s first review their 2009 decision (source Reuters)

Barrick Gold Corp (ABX.TO) said on Tuesday it had completely eliminated its fixed-price hedge book, allowing the company to take full advantage of rising gold prices and sparking a 7.6 percent rise in its shares.

Perhaps appropriately, the announcement came on a day the price of gold hit $1,200 for the first time, as the hedges -- which totaled 3 million ounces before Barrick began buying them back in September -- had become a symbol of the company's inability to benefit from a favorable gold environment.

"As of today, we are a fully unhedged gold producer," Barrick Chief Executive Aaron Regent said at an investment conference in New York.

The elimination of hedges comes earlier than the company had planned. Barrick said in September that it would get rid of all its hedges within 12 months, but sped up the pace due to the continued rise in gold prices.

"Our positive view on the gold price led us to accelerate the elimination of these contracts ahead of the schedule we had established," Regent said in a statement.

Fast forward to today with the price of gold significantly off its 2011 high.  Kitco today is reporting that some miners might start re-evaluating this strategy and might turn to hedging again.  The decision to close their hedge books was perceived as bullish for the price of gold going forward.  Should miners start to open hedge books again I would perceive this as bearish for the price of the yellow metal going forward.  Only time will tell but it is an important factor that we should keep our eyes on.

From Kitco News:

FOCUS: Some Gold Miners May Rethink Hedging As Costs Rise, Prices Fall

Rising costs and the drop in gold prices last month might put some gold miners in the uncomfortable position of having to consider hedging production.

Production hedging is done to guard against downside price movements and is common in many commodity-based industries. In agriculture, for instance, farmers and other producers will hedge future output to help make at least some of their production price neutral. This can be done by selling futures contracts or through more sophisticated options or other forward contracts. The idea is that if prices go up, the commodity on hand offsets losses from the hedge, while if commodity prices fall, the hedge makes up for the discount the producer takes on the physical commodity.

In metals, however, production hedging is often frowned upon. In the 1990s, hedging was common place when prices were much lower and gold prices were in a bear market. It was big news several years ago when major producers like Barrick announced in 2009 that it was closing its hedge book.

Erica Rannestad, commodity analyst at CPM Group, explained why production hedging in metals can be loathed by corporate shareholders and others: “Some companies don’t want to hedge their primary metal; they feel that hedging represents a lack of belief (in production/prices).”

For some miners, that might be a luxury they cannot afford. Miners have struggled lately with rising operational costs and shareholders are demanding miners hold the line on costs. When gold prices were near their all-time nominal high of $1,925 an ounce, shareholders turned a blind eye to costs, but when the price of gold was stagnating in the upper $1,500 to the lower $1,600s an ounce, reining in costs became important. Then came the mid-April price break.

When prices dipped to the $1,320s area, it started to come close the marginal cost of production plus sustaining capital expenditures, called “all-in costs.” Estimates of those costs range between $1,200 and $1,300, analysts said.

In fairness however, we should point out that this isn’t a done deal.  However, the fact that it is even being discussed may give us some clues as to where the major miners think the price of the yellow metal may be heading.

Not everyone believes that miners will not turn to hedging. Robin Bhar, metals analyst at Societe Generale, said production hedging is going to happen at some point. “We think they have no choice. They can cut expenses, but they might not have a choice but to hedge. Equity holders like the upside they get from the gold price, but at the same time they don’t want the company to be out of business,” Bhar said.

Societe Generale’s commodities team is bearish on the outlook for gold prices and part of the reason is the expectation that producer hedging will put a cap on prices. “It’s one of the reasons why any rallies won’t be sustained. Companies will use the rally to hedge, especially if prices get back to $1,500-$1,550, they’ll use it as an opportunity,” Bhar said.

There is another aspect of hedging that is different now than it was in the 1990s and that’s interest rates are near zero now because of quantitative easing by central banks. That could limit interest in hedging.

“Unlike in previous cycles, any possible producer hedging is unlikely to serve as damper on gold, as it will be very difficult to use traditional forward sales hedging given the credit environment in the commercial banking sector,” said Bart Melek, vice president and director head of commodity strategy, rates and foreign exchange research at TD Securities.

Companies Mentionned : Barrick Gold | Generale | Metals X |
<< Previous article
Rate : Average :1 (2 votes)
>> Next article
Latest comment posted for this article
Barrick? They have already been hedging production from Pascua-Lama which is now little more than a pipe dream. What's Barrick gonna deliver when the hedges they already have in place come due. I can just imagine what will happen to PM prices if they  Read more
ccmhi - 5/1/2013 at 11:53 PM GMT
Rating :  2  0
Top articles
Latest Comments
Elizabeth Warren: The 14 Trillio...
02:15sneezy67
Good ideas...good information....but somewhat behind the curve...the water has already gone under the bridge.
Man Grabbed, Crushed to Death By...
00:00user4779
The "lump of labour" fallacy raises its tired old head yet again, mixed in with B-movie-style sci-fi speculation about a terrible robotic future wo...
Max Keiser Interviews GoldCore’s...
03 Julovertheedge
"The IMF said that Greece requires additional bailout funds of around 50 billion euros until 2018 under the current bailout conditions, and slashed...
Greece’s referendum
03 Julend
"History may judge him instead to have played a poor hand very well indeed." I'm quite sure both Macleod and Varoufakis will be quite disa...
Gold Daily and Silver Weekly Cha...
02 Julglasstiger
Jesse, you use the term "could care less" frequently. Is this American speak for "couldn't care less"? Similar I suppose to the ubiquitou...
One more book, Mr. Stockman
02 Juluser4779-1
While it is true that "[Gold standards] were abused, suspended, and ultimately abandoned in favor of a currency that central banks could inflate at...
Panicked Hedge Funds Now Praying...
30 Junovertheedge1
"... and the silly game theory ..." Obviously you have no knowledge of game theory and its applications. Otherwise you wouldn't have used ...
The Gold Standard: Generator & P...
30 Junuser4779
Is it really so bad for Americans that they do not spend their lives labouring on a production line to make mass-produced goods, and have left this...
Most commented articlesFavoritesMore...
World PM Newsflow
ALL
GOLD
SILVER
PGM & DIAMONDS
OIL & GAS
OTHER METALS
Mining Company News
Gray Rock(Au)GRK.V
Gray Rock Closes Non-Brokered Private Placement
CA$ 0.02+0.00%Trend Power :
Corporate news
PetrobrasPBR
Petrobras to Sell Stake in Bijupira & Salema Fields for $25M - Analyst Blog
US$ 8.83+2.08%Trend Power :
Corporate news
BP plc(Ngas-Oil)BP
BP to Settle Federal, State GoM Oil Spill Claims for $18B - Analyst Blog
US$ 41.29+5.14%Trend Power :
Corporate news
Clean EnergyCLNE
ALLETE Clean Energy Acquires Wind Farm in Pennsylvania - Analyst Blog
US$ 5.37-0.56%Trend Power :
Corporate news
Junex(Ngas)JNX.V
Junex Closes a Portion of its Private Placement for Proceeds of $5 Million
CA$ 0.80+0.00%Trend Power :
Corporate news
Yingli GreenYGE
SHAREHOLDER ALERT: Pomerantz Law Firm Reminds Shareholders With Losses on Their Investment in Yingli Green Energy Holding Co. Ltd. of Class Action Lawsuit and Upcoming Deadline - YGE
US$ 1.15-3.36%Trend Power :
Corporate news
Sandspring Res.SSP.V
IIROC Trading Halt - SSP
CA$ 0.12+0.00%Trend Power :
Corporate news
Fortune Minerals(Ag-Au-Co)FT.TO
Receives Notice of Default Under Prepay Facility and Reaches Agreement in Principle to Settle
CA$ 0.05+11.11%Trend Power :
Corporate news
PetrobrasPBR
Indian Tycoon Plans to Invest $2.5 Billion in Brazil Oil and Gas
US$ 8.83+2.08%Trend Power :
Corporate news
Potash Corp.POT.TO
K+S says no basis for talks suggested by Potash Corp
CA$ 39.26+0.98%Trend Power :
Corporate news
Comments closed
  All Favorites Best Rated  
Barrick? They have already been hedging production from Pascua-Lama which is now little more than a pipe dream. What's Barrick gonna deliver when the hedges they already have in place come due. I can just imagine what will happen to PM prices if they are forced to cover their hedges with physical PMs. Based on Barrick's track record it's time to buy when they start hedging.
Rate :   2  0Rating :   2
EmailPermalink