Churchill Mining

Published : December 03rd, 2015

03 December 2015 PDF ICSID Arbitration Update – Completion of post-hearing briefs

( 0 vote, 0/5 ) Print article
  Article Comments Comment this article Rating Follow Company  
0
Send
0
comment
Keywords :   Coal | Fraud | Georgia | Indonesia | Market | Police | Reality | Singapore |

03 December 2015 PDF ICSID Arbitration Update – Completion of post-hearing briefs

3cdbc14b-c538-472e-a523-480eb9f097a3.pdf

1 December 2015


AIM: CHL


CHURCHILL MINING PLC

('Churchill' or 'the Company')


ICSID Arbitration Update - Completion of post-hearing briefs


The Directors of Churchill (AIM: CHL) wish to provide an update on the international arbitration case the Company and its wholly owned subsidiary Planet Mining Pty Ltd ('Planet') are pursuing against the Republic of Indonesia ('Indonesia') at the International Centre for Settlement of Investment Disputes ('ICSID') based in Washington DC. The arbitration before the ICSID Tribunal ('Tribunal') arises from the unlawful revocation by Indonesia of the exploitation mining licences relating to the East Kutai Coal Project in East Kalimantan ('EKCP'), Indonesia, in which Churchill and Planet held a 75% interest through their relationship with the Ridlatama Group ('Ridlatama').


Indonesia's Application for Dismissal of the arbitration case on the grounds of document authenticity ('dismissal application') was heard in Singapore between 3 and 10 August 2015. At the hearing the Company and its solicitors argued that the evidence contradicting the dismissal application was overwhelming. Following the hearing the Tribunal issued Procedural Order 20, in which the Tribunal set out a number of questions to be addressed in the parties' post-hearing briefs. The Tribunal directed the parties to file two post-hearing briefs, the second being a reply. Churchill and Indonesia each submitted their first-round briefs in October 2015 and then filed their reply briefs in November 2015.


Churchill's post-hearing submissions focused on (i) the large and diverse body of evidence (which includes final signed drafts of the disputed general survey licences) to show that the allegedly forged mining licences were in fact authorised by the Regency, (ii) the legal and factual consequences of Indonesia's refusals and failures to produce documents ordered by the Tribunal (for which Churchill has asked the Tribunal to draw adverse inferences against Indonesia), and (iii) the consequences of Indonesia's failure to call as witnesses a number of key Regency officials who were directly involved in the events in question.


Responding to a specific question posed by the Tribunal to the parties, Churchill also made submissions as to the consequences of the refusal of the former Regent of East Kutai, Isran Noor, to attend the hearing. At the beginning of the August hearing, as a result of Mr Noor's refusal to attend, the Tribunal made an order excluding his evidence. This was a significant development because Mr Noor was the person who signed the exploitation licences for the EKCP. Indonesia does not dispute Mr Noor's signatures on these key instruments, but rather alleges that he was tricked or deceived into signing them. Churchill has argued that, without Mr Noor's testimony, there is no convincing evidence to support Indonesia's case that the exploitation licences were the product of deceit (let alone deceit by Ridlatama or Churchill).


In its RNS market release on 4 June 2015, Churchill had noted the fact that Indonesia no longer alleges that Churchill participated in the alleged scheme to defraud Indonesia. In its first-round post-hearing brief, Indonesia changed its case again such that it does now make allegations of forgery and fraud against Churchill (rather than against Ridlatama alone). Indonesia has changed its case in this way despite the fact that, on two separate occasions

before the August hearing, Indonesia represented that it was not accusing Churchill or its officers of fraud or forgery (written representations on which Churchill relied in the preparation of its case). Indonesia's fresh allegations were also not part of the case it presented at the August hearing.


Essentially, Indonesia's fresh allegations focus on a single former Churchill executive (who was not present at the August hearing, and who Indonesia has never requested for cross- examination). In its reply post-hearing brief, Churchill responded to these fresh allegations noting (amongst other things) that despite years of police investigations (the records of which the State was ordered to produce, but failed to do so) not one Churchill (or Ridlatama) employee or officer has ever been charged in connection with this affair. Churchill has also asked that, in any event, the Tribunal declare that Indonesia is barred (by its prior representations referred to above) from changing its case in this respect. The point Churchill has made is that Indonesia's late change of case threatens Churchill's right to procedural fairness.


The filing of the parties' reply post-hearing briefs signals the close of arguments in the document authenticity stage of the proceedings. The Tribunal will now consider the parties' submissions and will in due course hand down its decision. It is not known how long the Tribunal will take to deliver its decision.


Churchill Chairman David Quinlivan commented:


'We are pleased that oral and written arguments in the document authenticity phase are complete, and we look forward to the decision of the Tribunal. We maintain our position that the Indonesia's allegations of forgery and fraud are baseless. We had insisted Mr Noor come to the hearing, as he is a key figure in this dispute and our counsel had a number of questions to put to him. We are grateful to Mr Noor's predecessor Regent, Awang Faroek Ishak, for his attendance at the hearing and for the apology he made to Churchill. Like Governor Ishak, we too hope that no future foreign investors in Indonesia will receive the treatment Churchill received. Indonesia has a bright future but the reality is a number of foreign investors suffered during the period of regional autonomy, and Churchill is one of them. The sooner this dispute is resolved, the better it will be for all concerned.'


Information on the progress of Churchill/Planet's claim against the Republic of Indonesia can be found at the website of the International Centre for Settlement of Investment Disputes at https://icsid.worldbank.org/apps/ICSIDWEB/Pages/default.aspx (under cases for 'Churchill').


END


For further information, please contact:


Churchill Mining plc David Quinlivan Nicholas Smith Russell Hardwick

+ 61 8 6382 3737

Northland Capital Partners Limited

Edward Hutton/William Vandyk

+44(0)20 7382 1100

Read the rest of the article at www.noodls.com
Data and Statistics for these countries : Georgia | Indonesia | Singapore | All
Gold and Silver Prices for these countries : Georgia | Indonesia | Singapore | All

Churchill Mining

CODE : CHL.L
ISIN : GB00B1318J18
Follow and Invest
Add to watch list Add to your portfolio Add or edit a note
Add Alert Add to Watchlists Add to Portfolio Add Note
ProfileMarket
Indicators
VALUE :
Projects & res.
Press
releases
Annual
report
RISK :
Asset profile
Contact Cpy

Churchill Mining is a exploration company based in United kingdom.

Churchill Mining holds various exploration projects in Indonesia.

Its main exploration property is EAST KUTAI COAL in Indonesia.

Churchill Mining is listed in Germany and in United Kingdom. Its market capitalisation is GBX 586.9 millions as of today (US$ 686.8 millions, € 632.3 millions).

Its stock quote reached its highest recent level on July 09, 2010 at GBX 99.40, and its lowest recent point on June 30, 2023 at GBX 0.16.

Churchill Mining has 163 016 118 shares outstanding.

Your feedback is appreciated, please leave a comment or rate this article.
Rate : Average note :0 (0 vote) View Top rated
 
Corporate Presentations of Churchill Mining
4/8/2008Blue Oar Research Note
In the News and Medias of Churchill Mining
4/10/2008 Minesite Article
Nominations of Churchill Mining
8/13/2008Appointment of Technical Director
Project news of Churchill Mining
7/23/2009(East Kutai Coal)Project Update
5/18/2009(East Kutai Coal)Doubles Resource to hit 3,18 billion tonnes
3/5/2009(East Kutai Coal)Project Update
12/8/2008(East Kutai Coal)More than 500Mt of coal at low strip ratios shown by prelimi...
11/10/2008(East Kutai Coal)EKCP Project Update
9/5/2008(East Kutai Coal)JORC Resource Update
6/23/2008(East Kutai Coal)East Kutai Project Update
5/27/2008(East Kutai Coal)RAISES COAL RESERVE TARGET BY 50% AT EAST KUTAI COAL PROJECT
4/8/2008(East Kutai Coal)Financial Times New Tenements Acquired
4/2/2008(East Kutai Coal)acquires control of strategic new tenements
3/10/2008(East Kutai Coal)begins Scoping Study & appoints new geological consultants f...
Corporate news of Churchill Mining
7/29/201629 July 2016 PDF Total Voting Rights
7/4/201601 July 2016 PDF Share Issue
6/22/201622 June 2016 PDF Timing of Decision on Indonesia's Forgery D...
6/20/201620 June 2016 PDF Update on Indonesia's Forgery Dismissal App...
5/6/201606 May 2016 PDF Results of Meeting
5/6/201606 May 2016 PDF Notice of General Meeting
5/6/201606 May 2016 PDF Update on Indonesia's Default in ICSID Proce...
5/2/201603 May 2016 PDF Total Voting Rights
4/20/201620 April 2016 PDF Update on Indonesian Default
4/14/201613 April 2016 PDF Notice of General Meeting
4/14/201614 April 2016 PDF Indonesia Defaults in ICSID Proceedings
4/5/201605 April 2016 PDF Issue of Equity and Warrants
4/1/201601 April 2016 PDF Total Voting Rights
1/7/201607 January 2016 PDF Issue of Shares
12/23/201523 December 2015 PDF ICSID Update - Response to Indonesian M...
12/23/201523 December 2015 PDF Result of AGM/Grant of Options
12/3/201502 December 2015 PDF ICSID Arbitration Update – Completion o...
12/3/201503 December 2015 PDF ICSID Arbitration Update – Completion o...
11/26/201526 November 2015 PDF 2015 AGM Notice
11/22/201522 November 2015 PDF Annual Report period ending 30 June 201...
5/3/2011Placement to Indonesian Parties to Raise £7.7 Million
5/26/2010Placing to raise GBP 16.1 million and Mining Reserve Update
4/27/2010PLN seeking partners to develop coal mines
4/8/2010Secures key Pilbara manganese tenement
1/11/2010Caesars Report
11/2/2009Coverage
9/30/2009Coverage
9/29/2009Statement re Press Speculation
8/26/2009JORC Category Update
7/17/2009Coal Indo Update July09
5/27/2009Issue of Equity
3/10/2009Coverage 2009
2/9/2009Coverage 2009
2/4/2009RNS Churchill Mining
1/12/2009RNS - Alliance Heads of Agreement signed with Leighton
12/24/2008RNS Churchill Mining
12/12/2008Dec Press Coverage
12/5/2008RNS Holdings in Company
11/25/2008RNS Notice of AGM
11/13/2008Nov Press Coverage
9/12/2008Blue Oar Note
8/28/2008Release Schedule of JORC Update
8/21/2008Coverage
8/5/2008Spitfire Drilling and Exploration Update
7/28/2008Drilling Update East Kutai Coal Project
6/13/2008Coverage
5/23/2008Spitfire Tasmanian Coal Acquisition
5/9/2008Mineweb article
5/9/2008Coal and Indo Update from Churchill Mining
4/15/2008 Press Coverage
4/14/2008Calculation of 250 Mt coal resources exceeds Q1 target by 15...
3/17/2008RNS Tinfos invests in Spitfire
3/6/2008City AM Article
3/6/2008Ambrian Research Note
2/29/2008Coal, the new black gold
5/2/2007COMPLETES 400-TONNE MINI BULK SAMPLE AT CHURCHILL PROJECT'S ...
Comments closed
 
Latest comment posted for this article
Be the first to comment
Add your comment
LSE (CHL.L)BERLIN (R9W.BE)
3.60-27.71%0.356+12.30%
LSE
GBX 3.60
05/21 10:10 -1.38
-27.71%
Prev close Open
4.98 5.00
Low High
3.60 5.00
Year l/h YTD var.
0.208 -  7.00 1,614.29%
52 week l/h 52 week var.
0.190 -  7.00 1,025.00%
Volume 1 month var.
26,295 1,630.77%
24hGold TrendPower© : -2
Produces
Develops
Explores for
 
 
 
Analyse
Interactive chart Add to compare
Interactive
chart
Print Compare Export
Last updated on : 11/13/2010
You must be logged in to use the porfolio and watchlists (free)
Top Newsreleases
MOST READ
Annual variation
DateVariationHighLow
20241614.29%8.900.21
 
5 years chart
 
3 months chart
 
3 months volume chart
 
 
Mining Company News
Plymouth Minerals LTDPLH.AX
Plymouth Minerals Intersects Further High Grade Potash in Drilling at Banio Potash Project - Plannin
AU$ 0.12-8.00%Trend Power :
Santos(Ngas-Oil)STO.AX
announces expected non-cash impairment
AU$ 7.72+0.19%Trend Power :
OceanaGold(Au)OGC.AX
RELEASES NEW TECHNICAL REPORT FOR THE HAILE GOLD MINE
AU$ 2.20+0.00%Trend Power :
Western Areas NL(Au-Ni-Pl)WSA.AX
Advance Notice - Full Year Results Conference Call
AU$ 3.86+0.00%Trend Power :
Canadian Zinc(Ag-Au-Cu)CZN.TO
Reports Financial Results for Q2 and Provides Project Updates
CA$ 0.12+4.55%Trend Power :
Stornoway Diamond(Gems-Au-Ur)SWY.TO
Second Quarter Results
CA$ 0.02+100.00%Trend Power :
McEwen Mining(Cu-Le-Zn)MUX
TO ACQUIRE BLACK FOX FROM PRIMERO=C2=A0
US$ 11.84-0.80%Trend Power :
Rentech(Coal-Ngas)RTK
Rentech Announces Results for Second Quarter 2017
US$ 0.20-12.28%Trend Power :
KEFIKEFI.L
Reduced Funding Requirement
GBX 0.77+0.66%Trend Power :
Lupaka Gold Corp.LPK.V
Lupaka Gold Receives First Tranche Under Amended Invicta Financing Agreement
CA$ 0.06+0.00%Trend Power :
Imperial(Ag-Au-Cu)III.TO
Closes Bridge Loan Financing
CA$ 2.59+0.00%Trend Power :
Guyana Goldfields(Cu-Zn-Pa)GUY.TO
Reports Second Quarter 2017 Results and Maintains Production Guidance
CA$ 1.84+0.00%Trend Power :
Lundin Mining(Ag-Au-Cu)LUN.TO
d Share Capital and Voting Rights for Lundin Mining
CA$ 17.78+1.60%Trend Power :
Canarc Res.(Au)CCM.TO
Canarc Reports High Grade Gold in Surface Rock Samples at Fondaway Canyon, Nevada
CA$ 0.24+0.00%Trend Power :
Havilah(Cu-Le-Zn)HAV.AX
Q A April 2017 Quarterly Report
AU$ 0.21-6.67%Trend Power :
Uranium Res.(Ur)URRE
Commences Lithium Exploration Drilling at the Columbus Basin Project
US$ 6.80-2.86%Trend Power :
Platinum Group Metals(Au-Cu-Gems)PTM.TO
Platinum Group Metals Ltd. Operational and Strategic Process ...
CA$ 2.56+1.19%Trend Power :
Devon Energy(Ngas-Oil)DVN
Announces $340 Million of Non-Core Asset Sales
US$ 50.04+0.04%Trend Power :
Precision Drilling(Oil)PD-UN.TO
Announces 2017Second Quarter Financial Results
CA$ 8.66-0.35%Trend Power :
Terramin(Ag-Au-Cu)TZN.AX
2nd Quarter Report
AU$ 0.03-8.82%Trend Power :